that girl ☠ (imafuzzball) wrote in _prisonbreak,
that girl ☠
imafuzzball
_prisonbreak

From Ask Matt


Question: I am amazed by all of the criticism of Prison Break. The same people who criticize it are people who watch 24, Desperate Housewives and Lost, none of which have anything but preposterous scenarios. The show never promised to be a documentary. Why can't we watch a show that is silly and unrealistic, rolling our eyes but enjoying it? Why must everything be so serious? I am surprised Prison Break has been so singled out for its less-than-realistic premise. Like a day with Jack Bauer is realistic? I don't see much of a difference. What happened to just having fun watching a show?— Kit

Matt Roush: I can only speak for my own criticisms, but as someone who embraces the notion of guilty TV pleasures wholeheartedly, I do have at least one standard even for junk TV: that I remotely care about what's happening. My problem with Prison Break boils down to this line from my most recent Dispatch about the show upon its inane finale: "Even the characters who were so promising at the start have been reduced to cardboard cutouts being maneuvered on a chessboard made of Swiss cheese." I don't expect everyone to agree with this, but I do bristle a bit when people keep asking "What's your problem?" when I've spelled it out pretty specifically. It's not so much the premise, although Prison Break's pretty much fell apart once they broke out and we followed too many characters through too many subplots of unequal interest. Comparing Prison Break to 24 or Lost on the basis of believability is pointless. It's all about the execution of a high concept. To me, that's where Prison Break miserably fails.
Tags: tv guide online
Subscribe

  • A Familiar Face Returns to 'Prison Break'

    Someone we haven't seen since the first season will be back It isn't unusual for "Prison Break" characters to return from the dead, so fans should…

  • Scoop from Watch With Kristin

    Prison Break: There Will Be Blood When Wentworth Miller bleeds, you pay attention. That's the clear message in our email inbox, which is flooded…

  • Spoilers for the season premiere!

    I posted this in my journal, but figured it made more sense to post them here, too. :) Spoilers: Vague and indirect, just the way I like them.…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for members only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 35 comments

  • A Familiar Face Returns to 'Prison Break'

    Someone we haven't seen since the first season will be back It isn't unusual for "Prison Break" characters to return from the dead, so fans should…

  • Scoop from Watch With Kristin

    Prison Break: There Will Be Blood When Wentworth Miller bleeds, you pay attention. That's the clear message in our email inbox, which is flooded…

  • Spoilers for the season premiere!

    I posted this in my journal, but figured it made more sense to post them here, too. :) Spoilers: Vague and indirect, just the way I like them.…