These actually took me less time that I expected!
Any sharable icons are first in the group.
drankmywar (all shareable)
(the fifth element, bring it on, btvs)
ba4ever (all sharable)
alternate 1 alternate 2 alternate 3
closemyeyes4eva (all nonshareable)
(melissa joan hart, buffy, smg) ;)
thebodyred (1 sharable)
(family guy, dita von teese, eri on crack)
gryffindorgirl7 (all shareable)
(idina menzel, william moseley, spike)
kally05 (2/3 shareable)
(b/a, soccer, robert pattinson)
taught_to_dream (2/3 shareable)
(buffy, michael ian black, brian kinney)
frontyardninja (2/3 shareable)
(xander, clean forks, peep heart, peep don't heart)
theleapingmuse (all shareable)
(darth vader, harry potter/lotr, buffy)
viciouswishes (all non-shareable)
(inara, db, wesley)
Please credit erithegreat! Thanks!