Young Geoffrey (ed_rex) wrote in _drwho_,
Young Geoffrey
ed_rex
_drwho_

Review: Listen, take two

Watching "Listen" (again)

Image: Detail of the Doctor at the new Tardis control console. Screenshot from 'Listen'.

The first time I watched "Listen", home after an 11-hour shift that followed an early rise, I wrote, "I definitely enjoyed it, definitely want to watch it again." I also wrote, "It sounds silly when I type it out, but [the story] gave me the shivers ..."

Well, hell. I did watch it again and now it seemed silly when I watched as well. There were no shivers to be found.

What was there was a mixed bag of an episode, combining Steven Moffat's still-effective skills at atmospheric scenes, with a show-runner's determined but mis-guided need to further place his singular stamp upon Doctor Who's cannon of mythology and back-story, and proof (as if any more were needed) that as a writer, he gives not a single damn for story-logic.

You don't have to read my review if you don't want your fun spoiled, you know. You really don't. Spoilers (in both senses of the term) ahoy!

Subscribe

  • Wholanta 2017 Costume track questions and info

    Wholanta, formerly known as Timegate, is the Doctor Who'verse and British media con in Atlanta, GA, USA, May 5-7, 2017. Please note the date change,…

  • Review: Death in Heaven

    Dissing Death in Heaven Almost there. With only a Christmas "special" still to dread, the 2014 slog that was Doctor Who's 8th revived…

  • Review: Dark Water

    Throwing out the Doctor with the Dark Water "Dark Water," the 11th entry in a 12 episode series, trundles along with a certain amount…

  • Error

    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 0 comments