Thank you for providing myself and the other "Carnivale" fans two seasons of extremely high quality television. I have to question your motives though: why cancel an Emmy nominated, highly acclaimed television series? I do understand that ratings are important to you, but HBO is paid for by the fans, not by advertisers. In eliminating "Carnivale" you are alienating a large portion of HBO subscribers; fans that are now canceling their HBO subscriptions, all because "Carnivale" is no more. I ask you to reconsider, I am very disappointed and am considering canceling my HBO service.