| The War On Drama |
[Feb. 26th, 2008|07:46 am] |
| [ | mood |
| | cynical | ] |
| [ | music |
| | Radiohead, My Iron Lung | ] | Wikipedia has gone and declared war on yet another a new enemy. First there were those wacky vandals , then the terrible Trolls, Sockpuppets, the Fair Use Doctrine and, of course, Badsites. Wikiland's new enemy? (you guessed it) Drama (the title kinda gave it away, didn't it?).
Drama in this case, means forcefully presenting and/or asserting a point, fact or view Wikiland doesn't like. It is, of course, a vague definition so it can be applied to a wide variety of cases. But it is basically aimed at those who are not vandals, trolls or socks. It is a more colorful, metaphoric way of declaring someone in violation of WP:POINT but who actually has a valid point which deserves to be addressed but Wikiland refuses to. If you can't come up with good evidence or a good argument, then come up with a label or accusation. When the tired, old labels and policies don't apply, and new ones have yet to be devised, accuse them of starting Drama (Like OMG drama! "Nono drama! You don't want no drama!":)
Of course, this ignores the fact that some of the biggest Drama queens of Wikiland reside, or once did, at the court of King James. We are talking such royal drama llamas as the likes of David ("Let's block an entire state and tell anyone who disagrees to fuck off") Gerard, Sooper Sekret Policeman Durova, Tony ( "Boy Toy") Sidaway, Slim ("Darling of Wikipedia Review") Virgin. And let's not forget, however much we may like to, perhaps the biggest, if not the fairest, of them all; Kelly ("Scott free!") Martin, whose futile attempts to regain power over and the respect of the community are starting to eclipse the dramas which lost her respect and power in the first place.
The King himself is not above starting some drama, even if he is well above being accused of such. For example when he blanked and protected his talkpage for 2 days last month, in support of a Chinese dissident blogger who was beaten to death. Here is my fav part, with which I have taken some small dramatic license:
"I humbly ask the Chinese Wikipedia government to consider taking steps to ensure that freedom of speech for the people of China Wikipedia is more protected. Stop censoring the Internet Wikipedia. Change laws to give strong protections to people who are speaking the truth. Do it for the interests of China Wikipedia. Do it because it is right."
How noble! What a bastard I am to accuse him of drama in this case. But consider that he also happened to be jet setting to Dubai and back during that time...how convenient. Also if anyone who is not James or within his charmed circle, pulled the same stunt, they would be accused of WP:POINT or Drama-mongering faster than you can say Falun Gong.
So the God king is once more shown to be a hypocrite and above the laws of his own kingdom...and until that changes, he lacks the moral standing to lecture anyone on freedom of speech. However, this is not news. Also while this was going on, his Star Chamber was in the process of censoring and censuring one of Wikipedia's finest editors and now most prominent dissidents; Giano. Gerard and Sidaway, whose actions brought on the situation and made it much worse got away Scott free again.
Giano's real crime was starting or starring in too many dramas. But drama-mongering is not against apelaw, yet, so they found another vague crime that is; Civility, which they define in this case as anything judged by an administrator to be uncivil, personal attacks, or (my favorite) assumptions of bad faith. Rather than meekly accept this bullshit, in a dramatic move, he decides to leave and join the WP Review. Who can blame him...well ArbCom obviously and now any block-happy admin looking for Cabal creds can, but I sure as hell do not!
All this reminds me of part of another drama, specifically, The Bard's "Julius Caesar" Act IV scene 1. (As my new friend, Mr. Moulton, likes to say; "The Process of Enlightenment Works In Mysterious Plays.":) Which I have, once more, taken some small dramatic licence with thus-
I now have the sad pleasure to welcome my friend and colleague, G, to the growing list of dramatis personae in the formally loyal opposition.
The small dramas on a titanic pile of nerd text and geek cultural artifact do indeed pale compared to those of real life. But where petty injustices are allowed to stand, larger ones usually follow. Makes me wonder whether, eventually, some future blogger here in our enlightened, freedom-loving West will suffer the same fate as Wei Wenhua for criticising Wikipedia or one of its successors, after their name gets added to some sooper sekret list of black sentence and proscription. But sorry if I'm being too dramatic. |
|
|