That apparently not letting someone who isn't in your guild raid with you is akin to racism?
I certainly didn't until I read this thread."Don't think I'm just saying this for the benefit of those of us who aren't in gravity. Just like a company that won't hire blacks, clannishness hurts Gravity. If you won't take people on your raids who aren't in your guild, then you are closing off opportunity for not only the people you reject (who can't benefit from your skills) but for the people in your guild (who can't benefit from the skills of those barred from entering)."
(This is from my realm's forums, Gravity is an allianceside raiding guild and this was originally spammed in their recruitment thread.)
NOW while I will concede that there is a point there in that taking people who aren't guilded can sometimes be beneficial due to the fact that a good player is a good player, the execution of it is ALL. WRONG.
After all, you can only recruit people who AREN'T already in your guild, thus it's necessary to take non-guilded people sometimes on test runs.
However, to claim that non guilded people automatically deserve a spot in guild runs and that it's unfair for raiding guilds to leave those people out is like, "WTF?" Raiding guilds run like machines and each player is a cog or a wheel. If you start throwing random screws in there, it will either go really really well, or things will just jam up entirely.
I have a belief that anyone who actually takes the time to go through an application process in order to get a spot does in fact deserve that spot more than a random class lead's friend off the street. But maybe that's just me, because the poster in that thread clearly disagrees. Asshats exist in an out of guilds, but at least sharing the guild tag is a slight sign that you can trust them more than someone else.
Guild alliances and PuG raiding can work, of course, but not as well as more organized guilds.
Thoughts, arguments, flames?