 |
|









 |
weirdjews
moonstart | |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
My cousin is on a pilot trip right now to decide where he wants to move his family next year. He is a nice mix of Breslov-frum and backwoods/guitar-playing/Xfiles-watching/b aseballcap-wearing secular. Basically, during the week he's Tshirts, jeans and cap, and on Shabbos it's strictly black hat and gartle... he's strict to halacha but incorporates the good of the secular world into his worldview. They're checking out Tzfat, Nahariya, and Ramat Beit Shemesh. I'm going to see him for Shabbos and he mentioned going to RBS next week for Shabbos to see how it is. No clue what neighborhood, but when I mentioned it to my fiance, he looked at me like this strange cousin may have just lost his mind, and shook his head. There was an article, which I cannot find, about a girl who was stoned (not "to death" but beaten badly) in RBS (Bet I'm guessing) by the Modesty Police. I found several articles, this being the most recent so far: http://jta.org/news/article/2009/07/12/1006432/residents-struggle-to-counter-violent-religious-coercion-in-beit-shemeshAnyone know what the status is in the community as a whole, and if this is something a person making aliyah would consider when looking for a safe, modern-leaning but frum area to live? Current Mood: contemplative
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |








 |
weirdjews
lavendersparkle | |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
I heard Shlomo Sands on the radio talking about his book The Invention of the Jewish People. I'm actually a bit perplexed about what the point of the book is other than to be misquoted by anti-Zionists and antisemites and get a lot of publicity for Sands in the process.
I haven't read the book, but going from what he said on the radio, none of the "shocking new revelations about the history of the Jews" is in any way new. I guess if your Jewish education stopped at 13, you might be surprised by some aspects of the book, but I'm not a historian, just an interested Jew, and I didn't find them particularly new.
One of the things he says is that during the second exile, most of the Jews weren't actually exiled. Who thought they all were? The Babylonian exile only actually involved the upper classes and left most of the peasants behind. There have been Jews living in Israel at every point since the exile. Who did he think wrote the Palestinian Talmud? Hadn't he heard of Jews being killed in the crusades?
His next 'revelation' is that Judaism was a proselytising religion and a lot of Jews are descended from converts. Again, no shit Sherlock. As if the references to conversion in rabbinic literature, the accounts of converts in Roman sources, the legend of the Khazars and the references to proselytising Pharisees in the Gospels, weren't enough to tip you off, I would have thought that anyone with an inquiring mind might have noticed that Russian Jews look an awful lot like Russians and Ethiopian Jews look an awful lot like Ethiopians and not attributed it to very fast evolution.
He also points out that our current understanding of nation states and race and ethnicity are quite modern inventions. Again, not telling me anything I didn't already know.
I think things get a bit odd when he goes from all of that to "So Jews aren't really a people/nation/ethnicity (as long as you use a definition of people/nation/ethnicity by which no group of people we currently think of as a nation would count as a nation, a definition of ethnicity which no one apart from Nick "my ancestors were here during the ice age" Griffin actually uses)".
I'm just getting this from an interview I heard. Anyone actually read the book and found something which is both true and not already common knowledge?
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |



 |
weirdjews
vvalkyri | |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
[crossposted to my journal]Now I know part of The Family Guy's schtick is complete tastelessness, but it didn't take reading the recent ADL letter* to prime me to speechless disgust with the second half of The Family Goy. [Edit: synopsis] I haven't seen much of the show, so I'd thought that maybe there was some attempt to highlight the stupidity of all the stereotypes by making it Peter using them, but then they're perpetuated by other characters, too. Along with some hateful actual lines and visuals. Jesus coming by at the end to say 'I'm Jewish and you're being stupid' was amusing, but seemed quite insufficient to undo the leadup to his arrival. Bad enough that. But then when I was about to post about it I read about something Real Life. Washington Post reports about a little anti-health reform gathering on The Hill** in the past couple days. Congressfolk who were happy to address a crowd who held signs like "Obama takes his orders from the Rothchilds"[sic], and worse: But the best of Bachmann's recruits were a few rows into the crowd, holding aloft a pair of 5-by-8-foot banners proclaiming "National Socialist Healthcare, Dachau, Germany, 1945." Both banners showed close-up photographs of Holocaust victims, many of them children. (Photo)
Immediately in front of this colorful scenery, various House Republicans signed autographs and shook hands with the demonstrators. Rep. Virginia Foxx (N.C.), who recently said the health-care bill is more dangerous than terrorists, gave out stickers saying "Govt Run Healthcare Makes Me Sick!"
"Who knew a casual comment on TV could generate this?" Rep. Jeb Hensarling (Tex.) exulted as he stood in front of the Dachau banner. I find this quite sad. And a little scary. * the one finding Doonesbury to be insensitive for a character's comment about moneylenders -- I don't find that strip particularly funny, but don't see it as anti-Jewish, either. (The rest of the letter had far more disturbing bits, but Doonesbury's what I remember)** the person linking to the article was commenting on the irony that several people in the crowd were tended to by "Medical personnel from the Capitol physician's office -- an entity that could, quite accurately, be labeled government-run health care."Tags: anti-semitism Current Mood: distressed
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |



|
 |
|
 |