SFSteve, redster, Lord Black Cat, catwhisker, Cardinal, Second Life, wooly, Comfy, Lightness, coffee, New bird, Yard Iggle

[info]kinzel in [info]theo_waitley

Need some eyes ...

We're working on it ...

which means that tomorrow we may end up with a day without Saltation .. .but if so, we'll try to make up at least some of the slack later.

Meanwhile, for those still needing something to do ... if you could visit
http://www.korval.com/fledgling/index.php and look around, we'd appreciate it. The plan is to make future work easier, and that's good.

Comments

Quick first look -- looks pretty good. I like the idea of having "suggest edits" and "discuss" separated. I use Firefox 2.0.0.14 with Vista right now.

Did notice that the Saltation page (http://www.korval.com/fledgling/story.php?story_id=2) seems to be missing some bold titles or something? Maybe just not there yet.

A day without Saltation is like a week without reading? :-)
Yeah, we haven't filled in everything yet, just the first few chapters of Fledgling. This is the "check for problems stage" so I can fix the little things first.

(Anonymous)

Well, then. We'll just have to come up with lots of interesting speculations to discuss.

Eta.
I like the new site very much! :) I'm using Mac OS X and Firefox 2.0.0.14.

Couple of little things I noticed - on the Fledgling subpage, the "Fledgling Home" link in the sidebar opens in a new tab; is that intentional? (It's not as annoying to me as links that open in a new window, but...I figure if I want a new tab open, I'll do it myself.) Second, shouldn't there be a link back to the main Fledgling/Saltation index page? I don't see one. (I noticed because I couldn't get back there via the back button when I was on that new tab opened from the "Fledgling Home" link.)
Yeah, I was thinking of adding a link to both the index page and the main Korval page. Think I should make it open in a new tab just for Korval since that's kind of a "separate" site?
I agree with wanting a way to get back to the "main" Fledgling & Saltation page once you have been to either book. That's one of the first things I tried BTW. I selected Fledgling to check around, then immediately wanted to do the same thing with Saltation and oops, no link to go "back".

A korval.com link should open in a new tab - a back link doesn't have to IMO.
I'm using Windows XP and Firefox 2.0.0.14


Think I should make it open in a new tab just for Korval since that's kind of a "separate" site?

That would make more sense to me. :) I wouldn't mind having Korval open in a new tab, but I'd definitely prefer to have all the Fledgling/Saltation links open in my current tab.

(Anonymous)

When I began creating my own webpages several years ago, I was informed that the tradition is that if the link you're referencing is on a different website/server and is totally seperate (ie, another webmaster's work) it's considered polite to open a new window.
However I have since noticed a lot of "own site" pop-ups (surveys, mostly) also are used in addition to other folk's banners and spam advertising on a lot of sites. Not to mention automatically generated cookies that may have nothing whatsoever to do with the actual site visited.

If, however, it's merely a picture on another site (to which you DO have permission to link with!) no special action (tab, pop-up, etc) is needed.

Seems to me this may be a fluid area and under the circumstances you could go either way with equal impunity, Zola.

Besides, the bulk of the folks here seem to be like pilots: intelligent, reasonable, and above all, flexible!


My opinion (which is mine, and belongs to me) is that if a link is going to open in a new tab (or even worse a new copy of the browser) please warn me first. I prefer to not have it open a new anything, if I want it in a new whatever then I can right-click and select "open in new whatever".
Without labels, it isn't clear what the input boxes under Donate are meant to be.

I usually advocate WordPress for this sort of project, but this is clearly something else. If you don't mind my asking... what is it?
The "Next" link from Chapter 4 leads to Chapter 4 for me - I'm currently using Portable Firefox 2.0.0.14 on WinXP. Other than that, it looks good to me!
Oh, good catch--looks like it's not calculating the value correctly.

*adds to bug list*

(Anonymous)

New interface for Fledgling

Ch 2
Tried the "Edit" and "Discuss" button - didn't work. I am using
Windows NT home browser: Firefox Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.8.1.14) Gecko/20080404 Firefox/2.0.0.14

"Print" button did bring up a window that could be printed, but no button on the window saying "print" (not that you really need one).

As for discussion: You need a period after
tiny, severely squared receiving parlor

Re: New interface for Fledgling

Yeah, edit and discuss aren't ready to be used yet, there will be a bit more coding to do there. ;)

Hmm... what's the consensus on the Print button? I myself was thinking more of it from the standpoint of the font and that it's in black and white without graphics... but we could put a button on there simply enough, you'd just have to scroooolll for it. :D

Re: New interface for Fledgling

What I've seen on other print pages was a button at the top that said something like "Send to printer." I think it invoked javascript to do the deed. Hum - yeah, the CNN articles have this.
I really appreciate everyone taking the time to look everything over, btw. :)

(Anonymous)

To Zola, your friendly neighborhood coder, Greetings!

Platform & access info: Microsoft WindowsXP, Windows Internet Explorer ver 6.0 over a dedicated high-speed internet link.

Index page for Fledgling & Saltation page looks very nice, good color choices & contrast, no font problems. Clean, classic and to the point. Lacks a "Home to Korval.com" link, but I note this is just Phase 1 testing, so time enough to add that, right?

Donate button on Saltation page takes you to PayPal but the one on the Fledgling page does not.

Saltation page does not yet have any chapters on it.

On Fledgling page: The Print arrow always got me Chapter 1, regardless of what Chapter I had actually pulled up and was looking at.

Edit & Discuss arrows apparently did nothing at all, and Recent reminded me of a really old caution in ancient IBM software manuals: "the results may be unpredictable".

A number of the chapters have missing spaces between words giving run-together ones. Examples from the beginning of Chapter 5: "ita", "thedisposal", "herface", "whenshe". General typo stuff, easily correctable.

Fledgling page shows 10 Chapters. Arrows at bottom of each Chapter are... interesting, but generally predictable. First button and Last button operate as anticipated from every chapter, jumping to Chapter 1 and 10 as expected.

Home button likewise jumps from each chapter to Chapter 1. Suggestion: is it not redundant to have Home and First if they both do exactly the same? Anyway, so far so good.

Logically, the Next arrow should move you from Chapter X to Chapter X +1 and the Previous arrow should move you from Chapter X to Chapter X-1.

The Next arrow of each chapter from 1 to 4 advances but then it refuses to advance beyond 4; pickup Chapter 5 from left-hand sub-menu and then the next arrow advances the rest of the way to chapter 10.

The Previous arrow on every chapter appears to do absolutely in single chapter advance-retreat mode; chapter selection from the left-hand sub menu advised instead.
Suggestion: scrap that arrow if can't be made to operate as it logically should.
Last arrow always jumps to Chapter 10 but then you have to use a different method to return to any prior chapter, even the one you came from.

Seems that these arrows could be simplified: forget about the redundant Home and the non-working Previous, present just First, Last & Next.

It could be that getting the Previous arrow operating properly without defining an html page for each chapter may not be possible, depending on how the pages are constructed (ie, framed, css, hand-coded or via a commercial html coding program).

Just FYI: I am a webmaster and retired software programmer & systems analyst but have never used any commercial html coding applications to create my pages; all are hand-coded but I have my reasons and believe they are good ones.

And in the time it took me to analyze the above and describe 'em, a couple of other folks found one or two.

(Anonymous)

oops

"The Previous arrow on every chapter appears to do absolutely in single chapter advance-retreat mode; chapter selection from the left-hand sub menu advised instead" should have the word 'nothing' between 'absolutely' and 'in single chapter'.

Sorry. I thought I did a better proof-read than that.
Donate button on Saltation page takes you to PayPal but the one on the Fledgling page does not.

This is actually correct. Subscriptions to _Fledgling_ are now closed.

(Anonymous)

Very logical, Sharon. In which case that donate button on that page isn't presently needed and Zola might easily omit it, even if it's presence isn't exactly "a bug"? Because if it's there and doesn't work, somebody might be apt to grumble about it.

Eta
Or, we might adjust one of the Trip Jar pages so that people who still wish to support the effort can. This is a possibility...

(Anonymous)

An even better one, O wizard!
I think that the calculation on the pages is choking for the forward and back buttons, so I have to look at the logic to see where it's dying.

Thank you for the careful detail, it is very helpful. :)

(Anonymous)

As one website coder to another... anything to oblige!

Eta

Little bit of general info

There's been a few questions already, so hopefully Steve and Sharon won't mind me just telling you a little bit about me.

My official job title is Developer, my specialty is UI (User Interface) and Front End. This is a custom-coded database solution. Heh. I feel like I ought to be getting the word "leveraged" in here somehow...

I can't give a lot of detail about my current job due to confidentiality agreements, but the work I do is at the level of big sites like LiveJournal, or Yahoo Mail, or even WordPress. I am capable, in theory, at least, of working on something like Google Maps.

I happened to stumble upon the Liaden Universe some years ago due to a review I read. I bought all the books I could lay my hands on, devoured them, and every now and again I checked on Korval.

Needless to say, I was delighted to see Fledgling and then Saltation.

I also saw that Steve and Sharon were terribly busy and keeping the site updated was taking a large chunk of time that perhaps they could better devote elsewhere, so I offered to set things up to make life easier on them.

I did a demo, and now we are in the Beta stage. I'm tracking down some of the messed up links now--some things seemed to get chewed up by the database import, so we'll be fixing them as we catch them.

One thing that would be helpful is to separate out questions of editing as opposed to the actual site. A mistake in the story text is simple and quick to correct, much like you can come here and edit a post.

Bugs in the framework that displays the stories, on the other hand, are solely within my purview, so that's what I'm concentrating on for the moment.

I hope this information is useful :)

(Anonymous)

Re: Little bit of general info

Yup. One or two of the items I mentioned regarding the framework aren't nearly as serious as some of the others I touched on, as I'm sure you're aware. I think you're doing fine. Take 5 and prioritize, then dive back in, eh?

Eta

Eyes

Its probably just my eyesight, which isn't very good, but the font used on Sharon and Steve's names make Miller look smushed together.
If somebody mentioned the news archive link I missed it. Doesn't seem to do anything yet.
Thanks for your efforts.

Re: Eyes

Oops!
Forgot the details.
Latest Firefox 2.0.0.14
on Windows XP SP2 with all updates.
8:52 EDT
Windows XP SP2
Internet Explorer 6 SP 2.

http://www.korval.com/fledgling/story.php?story_id=2 (Saltation page)

1. PayPal buttons images are coming up red-exed out.

2. Chapters header on the left is floating by itself. There are no chapters underneath it, nor does the word "Chapters" link to anywhere else.

Edited at 2008-05-05 12:54 pm (UTC)
yeah, the paypal buttons are going to do that once in a blue moon, since those are on paypal's server. Not much we can do about it, sadly.

There's no data in Saltation yet, so the header will be by itself.

(Anonymous)

Minor nit

OS X 10.5/Safari

If you click on one of the expandable links in the left menu bar, then click on another one (instead of the close), the first section closes correctly, but the close link still appears on the closed section.

(Anonymous)

More comments

Firefox 2.0.0.14, MacOS X 10.4.11

re: the print command - perhaps relabel it to make printer friendly? that way there is no assumption of a print button on the resulting page.

I only saw a few things that haven't already been mentioned (i think) that I'd classify as a bug:

Accessibility concerns - I ran the first page of the site through cynthiasays. com for section 508 compliance and WCAG Priority 1 and the only thing it really complained about was that the line_divider.gif needs an alt tag. Also, you may want to consider adding a skip links link at the top for screen readers to bypass all the nav stuff.

In the About the Authors section, most of the text is in a larger font then the other floating text areas (is that what they're called?) and is in the "clickable link" color, except for the last three words, and none of it is actually a link.

This may have been mentioned, if I opened the About $story link and then opened the rules link, the close next to the About link was still there even though the text went away when I clicked the rules link.

The rest of my comments I consider more stylistic preferences...
When you click on something in a left nav, I expect the text to show up in the main "frame" for lack of a better word then to stay in the left nav section. Nav area should be for navigation, only.

Once you've visited a link in the text, say the link in "5.Discuss the work in the Fledgling Live Journal community" you have no visual clue that there is a link there because it turns black (a.info_text:link, a.info_text:visited{color: #000000;) I'd suggest an alternate visited link color.

Chapter 1 does not need a first and a previous link. The last chapter does not need a next and a last link

Right now, both fledgling and saltation are using korval.com/fledgling/.... Will the final version have them separated into their appropriate directories? If not you may want an apache (assumption on my part) Alias or Redirect setup so either work.

I expect a Logo in the top left corner of a site to be a link to some sort of home page, whether that is the current story home, the stories home or korval.com matters less than that it is a link.

(Anonymous)

A "Latest Chapter" link would be good... I often forget which chapter was due to be posted, and have to re-read a couple to catch up. OTOH, perhaps this is a good thing!
You'll be taken directly to the most recent chapter if you use the "recent" button that's inline with the chapter title.
This new tool is definitely better than the old hand-coded pages. The old pages were fine as far as they went, but it's always easy for errors to creep in.

I don't mean to demean zola's work here, but I wonder if there isn't some benefit to putting all of the Korval.com site into a content management system like Drupal. I'd be happy to lend assistance there, it's kind of what I do.

(Anonymous)

I'm using Safari, and the initial text size is miniscule. When I increase it using the + function, it ruins all your formatting and runs stuff together. Please, for the sake of us with old eyes, start with a larger font! One thing that runs together is the "kind of complicated" with the "Latest News." When I get up to my usual reading font size, "kind of complicated" also eats "Phase 1" and the date. The problem is the same on Fledgling chapter pages, where "kind of complicated" eats into the first paragraph of the chapter and on the Saltation lead page. Thanks! Adrianne

(Anonymous)

Typo Alert Chapter 3 - Roni is a he?

Well, duh, I know Roni's female but Chapter 3 uses some masculine pronouns/adjectives for her.

Looking great though - it's good to re-read it.
Lauretta