Karyn ([info]bohemianspirit) wrote in [info]snapedom,
@ 2007-10-04 17:59:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Portrait Scenarios: How the final scene should have been written
My sister and I were hanging out the other night, and we got talking about how the final scene of Deathly Hallows SHOULD have been written...


We were both incredibly disgusted that Severus' portrait did NOT appear in that scene. And I was talking about some of the discussion I've seen online, pro and con having his portrait appear in that scene. Most of the con reasoning I've seen boils down to something along the lines of, Dear God, NOT ANOTHER EXPOSITION DUMP! -- which one might rightly fear would result from Harry encountering Severus' portrait in the final scene.

The scenario my sister and I developed was much more elegant in its simplicity:

Harry walks into the Headmaster's Office. Portraits explode into applause, Dumbledore gently weeps, etc. THEN... Harry looks next to Dumbledore, at the newest portrait: Severus Snape, looking down at Harry with his usual inscrutable expression. All falls silent. Severus smirks, just a little, gives a clipped nod, and says simply: "Potter."

And then Harry responds either "Headmaster" (my sister's version) or "Professor" (my version). Because it's way too early, of course, for him to call him "Severus," but "Snape" would be too cold and reminiscent of his erstwhile loathing for the man.

And then the scene just plays out to the end. NO EPILOGUE REQUIRED! :-D

And Severus gets his due... unlike in *cough* "canon."



(Post a new comment)


[info]a_bees_buzz
2007-10-04 11:37 pm UTC (link)
But, that would mean Severus was dead. Which he isn't. :D

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]bohemianspirit
2007-10-04 11:43 pm UTC (link)
Well, yeah. ;-) But I could deal with dead if he at least gets his due recognition, instead of being swept under the rug like some kind of embarrassment to the Order instead of one of its key players for two decades.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]a_bees_buzz
2007-10-05 01:10 am UTC (link)
But I could deal with dead

I can deal with the possibility of dead in fanfic. If he's dead in canon, though, fanfic is limited to AU, canon-era stories, or ghost stories. I'm very happy with Jo having left out the portrait, as it gives us so much more scope to play with.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]whatthefuckbenj
2007-11-10 08:05 pm UTC (link)
Jo having left out the portrait, as it gives us so much more scope to play with. Not that she's did it on purpose has it? When I read DH I thought she'd found a great way around telling 100 % if he's dead or not.. until she gave that interview :(

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]a_bees_buzz
2007-11-10 08:24 pm UTC (link)
On purpose? Maybe not. I choose to believe that her subconscious wouldn't let her finalize his death. Which means that whatever she says in interviews really doesn't matter.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]whatthefuckbenj
2007-11-11 01:48 pm UTC (link)
Yeah when it comes to Severus she must do most things unconsciously or else she wouldn't think so low of him!

ps: love your icon!

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]a_bees_buzz
2007-11-11 02:15 pm UTC (link)
And I love yours! *wants detention*

Mine was made for me by monique_27. She found the perfect sneering face for it, IMHO.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]franciskerst
2007-10-05 10:04 am UTC (link)
Quite my position: Snape has no portrait, no funeral and no tomb. So...

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]a_bees_buzz
2007-11-10 08:25 pm UTC (link)
Absolutely. Jo can say what she likes, but the books are done now and she's left us gaping loopholes we can sail the ships of fanfic through.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]starlightforest
2007-10-05 01:51 am UTC (link)
I think Harry is just beginning to re-examine his ideas of Snape at this point. In the book it gives an impression that he did an instant 180, but I don't think that's really the case. Whatever he said to Voldemort, there's clearly more examination of thoughts and feelings that will need to happen. So perhaps "Headmaster", but with a slight pause first.

(Reply to this)


[info]pearlette
2007-10-05 08:39 am UTC (link)
Well ... you and your sister both rock. *grins broadly* That was just lovely, and perfectly judged. *sniffle*

And I think I'll go with your choice of "Professor". :)

I really would have loved, in canon, some kind of reconciliation and closure - well, OK, the beginnings of closure - for Snape and Harry while Snape was still alive. :( We do see Harry's perception change, of course. But ... oh, what opportunities wasted. What might have been. :(

But I do like how the lack of a portrait gives that great let-out clause to the Snape fans, that he's not really dead. ;)

This was wonderful though. Thanks! (If only Jo Rowling had had an editor who thought like you ...)

P.S. I must be one of the five people in fandom out there who don't actually hate the Epilogue, although I do wish she had written it rather differently! I'm a fan of DH, despite the Snape issues, but the book ends far too abruptly after Harry kills Tom, IMO. But, yeah ... no portrait means that Sev is still out there. Somewhere. :)

(Reply to this)


[info]whatthefuckbenj
2007-11-10 08:10 pm UTC (link)
If Snape must be dead then I'd like to have your scenario =) (though he's not XD )

(Reply to this)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…