So many gems in this one - you guys keep getting funnier and funnier, I swear ;) So feel free to comment on each other's captions here, and let me know what you thought about this challenge, if you liked the "boat" prompt or not, ideas for new challenges or other activities, and again, as you can see
whisper_lillies has been posting away - you can too! Post anything pirate-related, and I'll approve it and we'll all have a merry ol' time, savvy? Okay, enough with my rambles, on with the captions!

Jack: Toy boat, toy boat, toy boat.
Guard on the right: Gone a bit soft in the head, he has.
Guard on the left: It's all the rum, and sun, and....sodomy.
Jack: Toy boat, toy boat, toy boat. Jackie wants a toy boat.
-from
melamseriousJack: "Our love is like a boat on the ocean, we've been sailing with a cargo full of love and devotion! Ship! I mean - I mean ship... sorry. Applause for Captain Jack and his wonderful singing?"
-from
abbey1969Jack: "Yes... it is a mighty fine bath toy... can I please have my boat back now?"
-from
whisper_lilliesJack: I sunk my boat --er, ship, ship! and am now on the shit list with the admiralty?
Norrington: Quite, former-captain Sparrow.
Jack: What say you to half the swag in my hold and I go free?
Norrington: ...
Jack: Awright, all the swag?
Norrington: ...
Jack: ... Like bondage?
-from
empress_izzyMurtogg's Gun (thinking): I hate being on boats. I get all rusty.
Murtogg (thinking): Damn, that's some complicated hair...
Mullroy's Gun (thinking): Point me at him! I wanna shoot something!
Mullroy (thinking): What's Murtogg staring at?
Jack: Irons, please? I like the ones with the soft lining.
Everyone (except Norrington, who's off-screen): WTF?
Norrington, who's off-screen: Take him to my cabin.
-from
estelendurMullroy: You really think he likes what you're doing?
Murtogg: Sure, I mean ... look how his muscles switch and ... sweet mother of...!
Jack: Release, please?
-
distelhadVOTE FOR YOUR TOP 3 FAVES IN THE POST BELOW BEFORE FRIDAY THE 15TH!