bialogue ([info]bialogue) wrote in [info]postqueer,
@ 2008-07-04 01:43:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Current location:Boston MA USA
Current mood: shocked
Current music:"We're Not Gonna Take It" by Twisted Sister

[USA] Bi Personals Site Boots Trans Member
as reported in Bay Windows by Ethan Jacobs staff reporter
Wednesday July 2nd 2008 and UPDATED July 3 2008



When Nick Teich created a free account on the online personals site BisexualDatingNow.com last week, he decided to disclose that he is transgender. Perhaps he shouldn’t have.

"They say, tell us about yourself in your own words. And I stated, ’I’m a 25-year old trans guy living in Boston.’ . . . I didn’t want to mislead anyone looking at my profile, so that’s why I put that," said Teich. Within a day he had received three "smiles," which members send to express their interest in getting to know each other.

Teich thought little of his decision until he wrote to the site’s customer service staff about a problem he was having using the site. He exchanged e-mails with a customer service representative named Kiar Dupuis, and after reading his profile Dupuis informed him that the site does not allow transgender users.

"I am sorry, as a transgender, our site would not meet your needs. I am afraid we have to remove your profile," wrote Dupuis, according to an e-mail provided to Bay Windows by Teich. His profile was deleted shortly after he received the e-mail.

BisexualDatingNow.com is owned by the Seattle-based company TangoWire, which owns a network of personals sites catering to a range of interests, from the LGB community to different racial and ethnic communities to motorcycle enthusiasts. An FAQ section of the BisexualDatingNow.com site describes TangoWire as a gay-owned and operated company: "TangoWire was founded by, is directed by, and is run by gay personnel. We don’t discriminate against our straight co-workers - they’re cool people, too, and just as committed to your great experience on our site."

Prior to transitioning Teich had joined one of TangoWire’s lesbian sites, but he said he hadn’t been an active user. When he registered with BisexualDatingNow.com he assumed he was signing onto a completely new site, but in fact the profiles for each site are linked to one massive database, meaning that someone on one of the bisexual sites could view the profile of a member of one of the lesbian sites. One of Dupuis’s e-mails to Teich accused him of trying to force his way onto the lesbian site.

"We do not have a site appropriate for transgenders. You joined our lesbian site, which is not your sexual preference. You then listed yourself as a bisexual man. This is absolutely a violation of our community rules because we do not allow any man on a lesbian site," wrote Dupuis. "You are NOT a lesbian therefore you cannot and will not be a part of our lesbian community."

Brian Brown, chief technical officer for TangoWire, confirmed that the company does not allow transgender people to create profiles on the site. When asked why identifying as transgender would exclude someone from identifying as bisexual and placing a personal ad on a bisexual dating site, Brown reiterated that TangoWire’s site does not accommodate transgender people.

"It’s that T side [in LGBT] that we have not been able to fully accommodate within our program. That is shown [by the fact] that in our registration, transgender is not one of the options we provide, and we don’t provide that as such. . . . That identity is not an identity we have an ability to support," said Brown.

He said that while Teich’s disclosure of his trans status played a role in the deletion of his profile, the primary reason he was removed is that he changed his profile on the TangoWire network of sites from lesbian to bisexual male.

"We don’t support bisexual males on a lesbian site. . . . When you sign up in our network your original site of registration is the site you get oriented in," said Brown. He said Teich violated the company’s terms of service by changing the gender on his profile.

Teich said he was angry when told that he was being booted from the site for identifying as transgender.

"I was in absolute shock when I saw that e-mail. . . . I was really upset. I was really angry. And I know that these people are ignorant, but it didn’t roll off my back that easily," said Teich, who contacted Bay Windows about the incident and reported it to the legal hotline of Gay and Lesbian Advocates and Defenders. He said he might file a complaint against the company with civil rights authorities in Seattle.

Daryl Herrschaft, director of Human Rights Campaign’s (HRC) Workforce Equality Project, said that HRC works to educate gay-owned businesses about the transgender community, but he could not recall an instance of a gay-owned business being so blatant in discriminating against transgender people.

"We created a guide called ’Small Business Basics’ along with the National Gay and Lesbian Chamber of Commerce, and what that guide does, it was geared towards small business owners and people affiliated with the National Gay and Lesbian Chamber of Commerce, many of which are gay-owned businesses. The guide addresses transgender issues. ... That being said, I am not familiar of another specific example of something like this," said Herrschaft.

Brown told Bay Windows that despite TangoWire’s exclusion of transgender customers the company strongly supports the LGBT community.

"The founder and CEO is gay, and we have an operations person who is gay. It’s a very liberal workforce and company as a whole," said Brown.


Please click here to read full article in Bay Windows: http://www.baywindows.com/index.php?ch=news&sc=glbt&sc2=news&sc3=&id=76889




Take Action: Please contact Bi Dating Now and their parent company TangoWire and let them know that discrimination against transgender people is not and never has been a part of the Bisexual & Pansexual Community's ethos. Tell them that our community is NOT interested in discriminating and that Bisexual and Pansexual people are perfectly capable of deciding who they are attracted to without a corporate "Big Brother" deciding if it is in our "best interest".

There appears to be no general email address for Bi Dating Now or TangoWire listed. So you can try phoning them at 206-448-6901 or use their "Contact Forms"

o The Contact Form for Bi Dating Now
o The Contact Form for TangoWire

TangoWire Corporation
601 Union Street, Suite 1601
Seattle WA 98101
USA

206-448-6901

Also be aware that they do seem do be a rather proactive or aggressive company (depending on your point of view). A simple Google search quickly revealed these Consumer Complaints (there may be more didn't go past the first few pages):

o see this exchange on the Consumer Protection site Ripoff Report: Big Girls Galore, Tango Wire Corporation Poor Service & Refusal To Refund
o and this report also on the Consumer Protection site Ripoff Report: Avi Martinez; As Representative Of Adam & Eve Singles In Partnership With TangoWire Corportation
o and this one on the Consumer Protection site Complaints.Com: Jewish Dating Site: "JewishMatcher" run by TangoWire.com

And other blog discussions and sites revealed what seems to be a propensity for simply blocking messages from any e-mail address that sends them comments they don't like. But perhaps they've mellowed over time and may be interested in listening to polite and informed letters.



AddThis Social Bookmark Button


we are x-posting this, we originally found this info on [info]ftmichael's post on [info]ourqueerfamily and [info]neverbeuseless's post on [info]gsa_lj but it's quickly spreading across the internet, it's now on "Pams House Blend" too. That'll get some action for sure!





(Post a new comment)


[info]wafflelips
2008-07-04 02:02 pm UTC (link)
Thanks for posting about this...I have a profile with one of their sites. I contacted them and have also deleted my profile.

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]bialogue
2008-07-04 07:41 pm UTC (link)
not to be nosy, but can you tell me which site you went in on AND were there people there who might not actually have met your criteria?

we are beginning to think that the real story here is that TangoWire is a bit of a scam, that they "harvest" people and $$'s thru a large number of websites for very specific criteria and then put them back out to be "matched" with far fewer ones, basically male/female gay/straight

from others experience they do seem to be using the term "bisexual" to just denote "closeted"

thank you

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]wafflelips
2008-07-04 08:13 pm UTC (link)
I had largely positive experiences with the site. It was all free when I first joined and I met some cool people through their lesbian personals site. I didn't know they had other sites until I moved from CA to NM last year. Everyone I met through it met the criteria that I had searched for.

I'm not sure what you mean about bisexual = closeted on the site. They had a listing for a person's level of outness (everyone, close friends only, not at work, etc.) and I never encountered someone who had listed themselves as bi, but only because they were closeted. More often, I saw people listing themselves as lesbian because so many folks don't get responses when they listed as bisexual.

I actually liked that site better than others I had been on. It's too bad the owners are narrow-minded jerks.

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]bialogue
2008-07-04 08:33 pm UTC (link)
I never encountered someone who had listed themselves as bi, but only because they were closeted

no we don't mean the other customers were doing that, we mean the company TangoWire was doing that. On other LJ Communities bisexual people are discussing that once identified as "Bisexual" they were restricted to only looking at same-gender partners

so far we have two people reporting this (both initially thought it was a system glitch) but when they contacted the company the reaction was confusion that they would actually want to do that. Finally they were told they were not "allowed" to do that for a variety of weird and nonsensical reasons and both people eventually just gave up and quit the service

I am a computer person and I think the more likely explanation is that they really only have a very few "search" criteria, male/female, gay/straight, etc., etc. This is not a bad thing in and of itself EXCEPT that they have a large number of websites out there that promise (or more likely from a legal standpoint only imply) that they will find people according to very specific criteria. From anecdotal evidence that is not happening. Maybe it is all just a series of innocent mistakes but maybe not.

You probably had a good experience because you fit into the more general criteria of something like "nice lady looking for other nice ladies".

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]wafflelips
2008-07-04 09:39 pm UTC (link)
Oh, okay! Now I know what you mean!!

When I moved here (NM) I found out that tangowire had a bi site and the lesbian site, so I activated my profile for the bi site. I didn't use it much since moving (wayyyy too busy in grad school) but do remember wondering why the hell the site made it so difficult to search for partners of both genders.

I had to do a separate search for male, separate for female, thought the age ranges were grouped oddly, and it bugged me that there was no way to limit the search to a city.

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]bialogue
2008-07-04 10:03 pm UTC (link)
but do remember wondering why the hell the site made it so difficult to search for partners of both genders

so far anecdotal evidence has shown that bisexual men are just set up as gay and even when asked they still do not let bisexual men search for ANY women on the grounds of something like "lesbians don't want to be bothered by men"

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]wafflelips
2008-07-04 10:24 pm UTC (link)
Ummmm....wow. That's screwed up. Buys into that whole notion that all bisexual men are sex-crazed freaks. Nice.

Although on the one hand, I see where trying to keep the thing happening where guys are like "wow, a lesssbiiiannnn. come meet my girlfriend", but since it doesn't seem to be a problem with other sites, I don't see why it would be there (I never encountered it on any sites whether I was listed as bi or lesbian...although when my profile was public on myspace I got a lot of interesting requests, but that is a hazard of a myspace profile).

And then there's the whole notion that lesbians somehow need to have other people protect them from men. That kinda reeks of sexist attitude, imo, like the "poor girls just can't handle it themselves".

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]bialogue
2008-07-04 10:40 pm UTC (link)
and then there is the entire thing that they were NOT trying to meet lesbians they were trying to meet female-type people who wanted to meet male-type people . . . incuding other male-type people who like OTHER male-type people

I mean male person --> lesbian? doesn't compute

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]chitinous
2008-07-04 03:05 pm UTC (link)
Tangowire can bite me. They don't allow members in relationships to indicate their status as "available."

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]bialogue
2008-07-04 07:43 pm UTC (link)
hi could we ask you to please see the answer above and ask you the same question about your experiences with TangoWire?

we are trying to figure out if they are basically a scam

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]chitinous
2008-07-04 08:14 pm UTC (link)
The site I used for a while (until I found out about the above policy) was GoFishLA.com. I don't think they're a scam - although they do obviously use a large number of targeted urls to attract potential users. I used their free service for quite some time; after a year or so, they changed it so only paid users can see people's profiles. I found out about that after the whole anti-poly thing, so I was already not interested in continuing to use their service. They may have changed it back, for all I know - I haven't been to the site since.

(Reply to this)(Parent)

p.s.
[info]chitinous
2008-07-04 08:16 pm UTC (link)
hi could we ask you to please see the answer above

Who is "we," by the way?

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)

Re: p.s.
[info]bialogue
2008-07-04 08:36 pm UTC (link)
we are Bialogue a bisexual/pansexual political action group

http://www.bialogue.org/index.html
http://bialogue.livejournal.com/

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)

Re: p.s.
[info]chitinous
2008-07-04 08:43 pm UTC (link)
No, I mean, who are you, individually?

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)

Re: p.s.
[info]bialogue
2008-07-04 08:57 pm UTC (link)
oh today this ENTIRE overwhelming and unexpected deluge of replies on all the different LJ Communities we passed this info on to, [we were hoping that people would just go write spirited letters to the miscreants, but no such luck] is being answered by one person . . but I already called on my confreres this AM and complained, LOL!

my name is cynthia, I am a computer programmer which is why I am kind of taking notice to this stuff and going "hey - there is something going on here"

after all even though people may NOT want to realize this a dating site is nothing more than matching certain criteria no different than putting together a bunch of widgets

how do you do

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]mingerspice
2008-07-11 03:42 am UTC (link)
Ok those complaints you linked to are BIZARRE.

If they are true, tangowire has possibly the WORST customer relations staff I have ever encountered. It's like they're not even trying to keep ANY customers happy, never mind trans-, bi-, Jewish or otherwise.

Instead of "sorry you were dissatisfied. Come back whenevs if you change your mine!" (which is the standard goodbye, if they don't actively try to woo you back with enhanced membership for 3 months or other goodies) they actually said "Get lost, loser, and don't even THINK of suing us!"

Also, the emails quoted sound amazingly personalized and informal meaning that, if those complaints are accurate, a person was being paid to spend time being actively nasty to ex-customers (as opposed to cutting and pasting dull stock language). To wit, the site is alleged to have said:

You are obviously not happy here, and have equated us with ripoff artists. We don't want any member of our site unhappy or appreciate being called crooks.

I'd be careful if I were you! This company doesn't mess around when it comes to their good name and have already sued people for that and won a ton of cash because because of it.

You have violated a number of our rules, actually. Before you continue being resentful and so actively vindictive, we invite you to reflect on the very 'Christian ethic' to which you yourself refer. 'Keep thy tongue from evil, and thy lips from speaking guile.' Psalm 34:13.

Also, the dad guy is really kinda creepy and overly litigious.

(Reply to this)


Create an Account
Forgot your login?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…