Round 01 - Challenge 06 Results
Seizing the fact that the Internet is working right this moment, here are the results:



ELIMINATED:
by anat_daily #02 (-5 votes)

sorry :(




POINTS:

01 [ - = -1 ]
02 [ ----- = -5 ] eliminated







COMMENTS:

#1 - the colorings are all too similar & the crops are a bit boring.

02 - I don't like the colours
02 - I think the text is out of place on all three icons. I think a better effect could've been achieved by completely eliminating the text and letting the images speak for themselves.

I'm going to have to say the lesser of the two set is 2 - I think the ideas were really cool for the last two icons, but the texture overpowers Orli in the second one and the lighting, although good, gets washed out in the second icon. Also, the text is rather illegible in the 1st one...I like the daring of the set, but its all a bit much.

It was really really difficult to decide between these two. The thing that made my mind was that the giggly-icon "lost" to it's opponent from the other set. Both of the set's have two absolutely amazing icons and one that doesn't do it for me. "Shy" and "Hot" are definately beautiful and have amazing colors. This time just the third one wasn't enough to get me to vote for the other one.