She Who Procrastinates is ... last? ([info]procrastinatrix) wrote in [info]orbital_2008,
@ 2008-03-27 18:49:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Current mood: thoughtful

Four days on Raisa
x-posted from my LJ

Got home yesterday afternoon, after a brief post-con interlude with friends in Maidenhead, and now I feel the need to reflect on the whole puzzling Orbital experience. Puzzling because, in the main, I should not have enjoyed this, and the two other cons I have attended, anywhere near as much as I did since I am not in any way A Fan.

This is not to say that I don't like science fiction because I do, very much, and have done since my teens when I read first the excellent John Wyndham and then the less-than-excellent-and-extraordinarily-sexist Edmund Cooper, in some quantity. Fantasy too has been a occassional addition to my literary diet, beginning inevitably with LoTR at the age of about 14 and followed by a looooooooooooong dry spell until Husband introduced me to Tad Williams in 1990. However, I feel that merely liking the stuff and being A Fan of the stuff are two very different things. I can barely remember a thing about a book/film/TV episode/series once I have stopped interacting with it. For me it's all about short-term gratification - read/watch and move on. I can't recount series numbers, episode titles or plot details. I feel no sense of ownership of the characters or their milieu. If a book or episode is bad, I'm likely just to stop engaging with that author/series rather than to agonise about how the writers/producers have let us down. If characters do things that I didn't expect and don't particularly like, I may grump about it a bit but I accept that that's the way it goes with fiction sometimes. For Fans, I feel, things are very different. Which is not to say that Fan-dom is bad, just that I am different from A Fan and A Fan is different from me.

So why do I enjoy conventions so much when the whole premise of the event is that it serves Fans, a group to which I demonstrably don't belong? Answer is, I don't know. Since I am also not a particularly gregarious person, it can't be the opportunity to meet lots of people. I go to the occasional panel but am frequently confused and nonplussed by the content. I don't read an awful lot of fiction at the moment so have few favourite authors whose autographs I would seek out. I'm far too shy to get dressed up for the Masquerade. I did get involved in running the Easter day service this year, which was terrific but not unstressful.

I guess part of what I enjoy is seeing my partner and friends having such a good time - four days in the happy company of these people whom I love, admire and respect is no small treat. And I like hotel life, the self-containedness of it all, the slightly off-world feel*, the free shower caps. And when I do summon up the nerve to make conversation, I always find that very rewarding. Ultimately, I guess, it's about being part of something, no matter how peripherally, that matters to other beings. So while I a not A Fan, not part of The Tribe that Neil Gaiman talked about on Sunday, I like to think I am something of a fellow traveller.

In the world of transgender, where my research interests lie, there is a term SOFFA, standing for Significant Others, Family, Friends and Allies. Inspired by this, but not wanting to colonise someone else's discourse, I name myself a SOFTy - Significant Other/Fellow Traveller. Maybe at the next convention, if there are any other SOFTy around, we can get a drink together in the Real Ale Bar and swap stories about what it's like on our planet. Check us out with your bioscanners as you pass by - I think you'll find us harmless.

* like Raisa, while the world outside the Radisson Edwardian was harsh and forbidding, inside there was everything for pleasure!



(Post a new comment)


[info]jophan
2008-03-27 08:05 pm UTC (link)
But "fan" doesn't mean fan of a particular work. It means member of fandom. If you go to cons and enjoy them, you're by definition a fan, unless you refuse to accept the label for some other reason.

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]procrastinatrix
2008-03-28 11:49 am UTC (link)
I guess it's not so much about refusing the label as it is about feeling that I have done nothing to earn it - not read enough or seen enough or stored enough to talk about it later, if that makes any sense.

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]jophan
2008-03-28 12:04 pm UTC (link)
Hmm, I see what you mean. However, as the term "fan" is used within fandom, it doesn't refer to how fans relate to science fiction/fantasy, but to their being part of fandom. A common definition of a fan is someone who:

* writes or reads science fiction fanzines or blogs, OR
* organises or regularly attends sf conventions, OR
* belongs to an sf club that sees itself as part of fandom, OR
* participates on fannish mailing lists of web fora

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]procrastinatrix
2008-03-31 03:09 pm UTC (link)
Am now convinced by you and others that I can be a fan of cons, regardless of any other shortcomings on my part. So, I thank you.

By the way, what did you think of the beer in the Real Ale Bar this year? Was it up to your exacting standards?

Cheers
J

(Reply to this)(Parent)


(Anonymous)
2008-03-27 08:53 pm UTC (link)
Commenting from the next room - know what you mean, but suspect many/most/all are in the same boat - have tried to express this here: http://gyrovagueness.blogspot.com/2008/03/fan-envy.html
...BTW, tea is nearly ready.

(Reply to this)


[info]the_magician
2008-03-30 10:06 am UTC (link)
As [info]jophan says (sort of) a "fan" as in fandom, is someone who participates in fandom, regardless of whether they read sf, watch tv, write novels or knit clangers :-)

When you add a modifier (like "star trek fandom") then it becomes more focussed ... but I know some second generation fans, where their parents took them to conventions as a child ... some aren't big readers, some can take or leave TV SF etc., but they love the convention atmosphere, and the sort of people that come to cons ... people you can have a serious conversation with and who don't need to have, say, the doppler effect, explained to them (or if they don't know what it is, they'll stop you and ask rather than pretend to understand you!)

Fandom is in some ways our tribe, our extended family, but it's people we *choose* to spend time with (even if some of them are pretty weird!) and it's something we miss when we have to leave it again ...

... so I'm afraid that you "one of us ... one of us ..." as well as being a SOFTy :-)

But I've seen the same thing with folk music "fandom", where the kids come along to the festivals and as they grow older, they keep coming but with their own tents and their own bunch of friends, and the music becomes less important than the social aspect and many would say that they don't listen to folk music, but still they come ... and the thing about SF cons is that the more cons you attend, the less important the programme and guests become, because you're coming for the people and the atmosphere and the belonging. (Of course if you're not careful, you end up running the damn things!)

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]procrastinatrix
2008-03-30 10:20 am UTC (link)
I suppose I am fan of cons - and that's what I find so puzzling, cos I'm not so good with the socialisings. Under normal circumstances, if someone said to me "I'm going to make you go to this place where you have to mingle with upwards of 1000 people, none of whom you know and most of whom will be talking about stuff you barely understand AND some of whom might engage you in conversation about this stuff you barely understand, with the result that you may look foolish and ill-informed", I would have to respond: "No thanks, I'm washing my hair". But, call it a con and I go and have a whale of a time!

I suspect some kind of mind probe is involved.

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]the_magician
2008-03-30 10:32 am UTC (link)
Grin, yes, definitely (and for some, alcohol as well! And for the rest of us, sleep deprivation!!)

Given that
a) I was dashing around the con non-stop
b) My brain wasn't storing short term memory due to sleep deprivation
c) I'm terrible at matching LJ names to faces
d) ... something else to be explained at a future date (grin!)

... did I say hello during the con? Well, aside from up on stage when doing the opening and closing ceremonies and the cabaret? :-)

Well, I hope to see you at Redemption next February (Coventry) and Odyssey in 2010 (back at Heathrow) and I should be at LX next easter also (plus conrunner, novacon and the german filkcon this year ... a quiet year for cons for me!)

[Edit: doh, and now reading your profile I find my folk festival comment was coincidentally appropriate, as you have June Tabor, Richard Thompson, Eliza Carthy etc. on your list of interests :-) excellent! I'll be going to Cambridge and Cropredy Festivals definitely, and picking a couple of other ones to fill in when I know what my free weekends are ... and I really must get around to going to the local folk club and seeing if I can find people to sing and play with ....]

Edited at 2008-03-30 10:35 am UTC

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]procrastinatrix
2008-03-31 03:07 pm UTC (link)
Don't think we said hello but we certainly can at LX and Odyssey (nowhere near as busy a scheule as yours!)

Hope you enjoy the festivular activities too. We've been to Cropredy a few times (last was 2005, I think) and always had a really great time. Cambridge too, but waaaaaay back in the 70s. We keep saying that we'll go a-festing again some time but then decide our old bones aren't up to sleeping on the cold, cold ground anymore (much preferring the goose-feather bed, these days).

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]the_magician
2008-03-31 03:37 pm UTC (link)
I've done Cropredy every year since 2000, and the same or thereabouts for Cambridge ... used to do Sidmouth as well, back when it had a festival :-) ... I've done Trowbridge, Bridgnorth, Redditch and Arden, The Big Session (Leicester) and a couple of smaller ones ...

... for Cambridge I stay with friends who live walking distance from the field ... Cropredy I do sleep in a tent, with either a nice thick air mattress or at least one of those self-inflating roll-mats, but I know some people stay at B&B or rent a narrowboat, or at least a mobilehome/caravan/RV.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]kalypso_v
2008-03-30 03:28 pm UTC (link)
I was really pleased to pick up a new shower cap. The elastic was going on my old one.

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]procrastinatrix
2008-03-30 04:28 pm UTC (link)
I bagged two - one for now and one for later (?)

Disappointed by the soap dispensers though - damn their ecofriendliness!

(Reply to this)(Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…