So i was thinking about this the other day, sitting on the bus, handling my carte reduit/bus pass combo with care seeing as it is the only piece of picture ID i have left since i lost my wallet a month ago (for those of you who are avid montreal post readers and remember me, hi!)
A couple of days ago, I got a letter in the mail from the Health Insurance people telling me I need to renew my card, which is good i guess, since i need to get a new one anyway. The pamphlets within are familiar enough, telling me that i need to bring this paper in, along with 2 pieces of ID one including a picture. They list the acceptable pieces of ID.
As i man-handled the measly piece of plastic that shows that i am a person with an identity, I remembered what i had done to get it; I had to bring in a proof of address/residency and a picture ID. The STM lists the same list of acceptable pieces of ID as i the Health Insurance peeps.
So in reality, getting my STM card is exactly the same process as getting my health card and so in theory they represent exactly the same validity as ID. They are both pieces of plastic that proove i once showed someone a proof of residency and a "valid" picture ID.
This afternoon, I went to Biftek and the barmaid asked me for some ID. I showed her my single piece of picture ID à la Carte Réduit and she said, "That's not acceptable ID." I spared her my rant, but she reminded me of how it makes no sense.
I guess my question is: who do i need to fuck in this city to get La Carte Reduits considered as valid picture ID?
Because it's pretty much the equivalent of a Driver's License. Notice how if you have a driver's license your life is easier because you have an added piece of plastic in your wallet that says you're recognized by the bureaucracy. But what if i don't want to drive! What if i like fresh air and I believe adamantly in public transportation in the city for the good of the environment and for the good of society. WHY ISN'T THAT RECOGNIZED? Just because i choose to transport myself within the public service provided to me by the city, the ID they supply me with isn't worth shit?
And i suppose someone is going to tell me that it's because a lot of people make fake STM cards, and it's almost impossible to make a fake Medicare Card or Dirver's License, but I don't know if you've ever seen a phony STM cards but it's not like people make them very well since they're usually only viewed from a distance. Bus drivers don't carefully inspect them but if someone did, it'd be pretty obvious that they are fake.
And well then maybe my complaint is that the STM should make their cards less forgeable so that they can be recognized as "valid" IDs, since they demand you give them the same things that "valid" ID cards ask for.
Ya!