Community Profile

Advertisement

[info]knitting_review
  • Join
  • Watch
  • Add Note
  • Post
  • Track
  • Send V-Gift
Userpic

Knitting Reviews

Quality, not quantity

Created on 2005-08-25 11:36:08 (#8116180), last updated 2009-03-25

146 comments received

39 Journal Entries, 13 Tags, 7 Memories, 0 Virtual Gifts, 0 Userpics

Basic Info
Name:Knitting Review
Membership:Open
Posting Access:All Members
About
This is a community where you can post your knitting related reviews. This includes:

  • Knitting Books

  • Knitting Yarns

  • Knitting Communities

  • Knitting Websites

  • Knitting Stores



Rules


  • Do not promote your own personal business.

  • All reviews MUST be in form of a proper critique. Guidelines posted below.

  • If at all possible, link to the place/item/site that you're reviewing.

  • Spelling and grammar is enforced. A minor typo is forgiveable. Speling liek thiss is NOT acceptable. Most LJ satellites like Semagic do have spell-checks. Or just type it up on a Word Document first and hit the spell-check button.

  • Check The Memories First! If there is already an existing review on what you plan on reviewing and you have additional information, add a comment to the post.

  • Please mind your manners. Flame threads will be frozen and deleted as soon as one of the mods see it.

  • Requests for reviews will be tolerated only AFTER the Memories are checked first.

  • No crossposting to any of the other knitting communities.

  • Please use the scale (see below) in the Subject Line of the post.



All violating posts will be promptly deleted.

How to write a good critique
(Now this is how I like to get 'em, so this isn't law, per se, but consider them pretty strict guidelines).

1. The Good: What did you like about it? Why did you like it? What would you recommend?

2. The Bad: What didn't you like about it? Why did you dislike it? Anything in particular we should be aware of?

3. The Conclusion: Overall, what would you give it on a scale of 1-10, 10 being PERFECT! and 1 being NEVER AGAIN!. The scale is not optional, please give it a rating.
Connect

Interests (5):

knitpicks, knitting, yarn harlot, yarn snobs, zimmermann
Administrators

Maintainers (2):

jessimuhka, more_dragoncelt
Members [View Entries]

Members (144):

10ftscarves, 11_toed_wonder, _cassette_tape, a_cherry_on_top, adrinna, ailurophiledj, alceria, amonik, anastaciaknits, andraste_oz, anitram21, apis_mellifera, arlydwycka, atwood48, bardhorse, beachknitter, belle_marmotte, blaueteufelin, boo_kat, bookish_girl_, bopeepsheep, brier_fibre, bunnysquirrel, bytheshore, camiah, charlij, chasingmyself, chymerikaen, cimorenegal, citabriag, clearwater713, clstal, craftycrystal, crohooker, crownless, cthulhulovesme, deojuvame, desdemona, dorantherook, dragoncrafter, dragonintherain, drgnflydreaming, e_musings, emmacrew, ferret_herder, fezabel, firesika, froggy_knits, gardenwaltz, gishmi1ish, grassyslough, hazelstitch, hfnuala, hipknit, hobbitblue, hrvdmnky, i_harobed, irihs, jcipa, jessimuhka, jinjifore, jullia_starz, juneadelle, katinkorea, kninchicago, knit_witty, knittypretty, la_vie_tricote, ladyfrailty, leene_chan, lilith79, lilsailorknits, lisa_bee, malus_diabolus, margorand, meghan89, misfitnumber57, miss_binkowitz, misslemmon, moira_ramsay, molliewollie, more_dragoncelt, morgaine723, msfortuknit, msmcknittington, naixin, natsumi, neatlittlelass, nehnhaa, notafraidtofrog, nyctea, ohsochewy, ona_tangent, origamist, pixiecrinkle, platys, poet_girl_913, purplecat_a2, purplkat, quantum_kitty, quiet_angel84, ragingcanary, redmolly23, redstripedsock, rhi, rhitsqueaky, rockonlily, rocks_and_fiber, run_on_revolt, sarcasm_queen, sarcasticho, sian_ore, sicklipstick, silent_sister, sistercoyote, sm00bs, spookys_knits, stacyinthecity, stellathediver, strange_charm, string_2_sticks, studiotamar, susancalvin, sushiq, swallowedbysky, tacitcat, tark_lill, theknitpicker, thereyougothen, tjstein, twotone, umlautless, valancystirling, veeboochi, vvgrant, weaselmomma, webhill, weeble, willowannelyra, wyvernfriend, zardra, zipper208, zissa, zyllah

Watched by (130):

a_cherry_on_top, adrinna, ailurophiledj, amonik, anastaciaknits, andraste_oz, anitram21, arlydwycka, atwood48, bardhorse, beachknitter, belle_marmotte, blaueteufelin, boo_kat, bopeepsheep, brieza, bunnysquirrel, bytheshore, camiah, charlij, chasingmyself, chymerikaen, citabriag, clstal, corvid, craftycrystal, crickets_lj, crohooker, crownless, cthulhulovesme, dabblersupreme, deojuvame, desdemona, dorantherook, dragoncrafter, drgnflydreaming, e_musings, emmacrew, ferret_herder, fezabel, firesika, froggy_knits, galaneia, gardenwaltz, gishmi1ish, grassyslough, hazelstitch, hellesbelles, hfnuala, hipknit, hobbitblue, i_harobed, irihs, jessimuhka, jinjifore, jullia_starz, juneadelle, karenkay, katinkorea, keladryb, knit_witty, knittypretty, knottie, la_vie_tricote, ladyfrailty, lanewayne, leene_chan, lilsailorknits, lisa_bee, malus_diabolus, margorand, meghan89, miss_binkowitz, miss_tish, missingmurphy, moira_ramsay, molliewollie, more_dragoncelt, morgaine723, msfortuknit, msmcknittington, natsumi, neatlittlelass, nehnhaa, nnmpsn, notafraidtofrog, nyctea, ohsochewy, ona_tangent, platys, poet_girl_913, purlygurl, purplecat_a2, purplkat, ragingcanary, redmolly23, rhitsqueaky, rockonlily, rocks_and_fiber, run_on_revolt, sarcasm_queen, sarcasticho, sarkasmo, sicklipstick, sistercoyote, snerks, spookys_knits, stellathediver, sternel, strange_charm, susancalvin, sushiq, tacitcat, terrathree, thereyougothen, tjstein, tvini, twotone, umlautless, vvgrant, weeble, whittlnwithbear, willowannelyra, wyvernfriend, zardra, zigeunerweisen, zipper208, zissa, zoe84, zyllah

Advertisement

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…