Community Profile

Advertisement

[info]icon_crit
  • Join
  • Watch
  • Add Note
  • Post
  • Track
  • Send V-Gift
Userpic

icon_crit's Journal

Created on 2006-06-26 22:29:52 (#10538744), last updated 2006-12-04

543 comments received

53 Journal Entries, 0 Tags, 0 Memories, 0 Virtual Gifts, 0 Userpics

Basic Info
Name:Constructive criticism? Yes, please!
Website:icon_crit
Membership:Open
Posting Access:Select Members
About
Welcome to Icon Crit!  
[info]icon_crit is a sister community to [info]pickmybest.  Here you can post your icons and get constructive critism.   All icon subjects (aside from Adult) are allowed--Books, Movies, Celebrities, Anime, Manga, Music, etc. 

Please be aware that criticism may not always be pleasant, you won't find comments like Omg, they are all soooo pretty here. If you decide to post here, everything goes, we won't censure people's comments as long as they're not rude and disrespectful. Starting drama will get either of you banned without warning. Naturally there will be different opinions and tastes, try to talk through disagreements like sensible adults.

If you think there are problems that need to be taken care of, contact [info]ohfreckle at sanami276 at gmail dot com

If you'd like to post your icons for judging, read the Maker's Rules, join, and then apply for posting access.
If you'd like to vote, read the Voter's Rules, then start picking icons you think need improvement!


Note: All icons belong to their creators. Check their rules on sharing before taking any icons.
Voter's Rules Maker's Rules
  • Pick the five icons you think are of lowest quality by commenting on the same entry where the icons are displayed.

    For each icon state a reason, like "You oversharpened the icon, which makes it look grainy". 
    The more elaborate your reasons are, the more useful they will be for the icon maker who wants to improve. You can also make an additional statement if you have to say something that concerns all icons in the batch you're commenting on.

  • Feel free to comment on as many different batches of icons as you'd like.

  • Flaming and obnoxious behavior will not be tolerated and get you banned instantly.  Please treat all makers and fellow voters with respect.
    • </ ul>
  • The maximum number of icons in a batch you can post for judging is 30.  The fewest you can post is 15.

  • You can only submit one batch of icons per month. Try to post again when you feel you have improved, tell what you learned from the comments you received and what you changed in your icon making..

  • Do not re-post any icon if you included it in a previous batch.

  • Posts with broken image links will be deleted. Keep this in mind when deciding to display your icons here.

  • This should be obvious, but if we find out that any icon posted under your name is not your own creation, you will be banned.

  • All icons must meet LiveJournal standards.  100x100px max, and less than 40kb.

  • Since we'd like this community to be open for as many people as possible, adult icons aren't allowed.  Artistic nudity is alright, but please put a warning before the lj cut.

  • Mild swearing is allowed, and it will be up to the mods' discretion. It must be placed under the lj-cut with a warning.

  • No posting of brushes, textures, patterns, gradients, or anything else besides batch entries.

  • If you choose to code your own icon table, please put the numbers above your icons to keep confusion at a minimum.

  • Flaming and obnoxious behavior will not be tolerated and get you banned instantly.  Please treat all voters and fellow makers with respect.

  • Make sure you have joined the community.

  • Include the word 'criticism' in the subject of your application to post so the Mods know you've read and agree to the rules.





Administrators

Maintainers (2):

brighty11, unmasked_icons
Members [View Entries]

Members (108):

_dennis_csi_, alchemic_ll, alina_crystal, angels_airwaves, arjd, babyblueprep, bang2009, battleaxed, beetle_breath, benelie, brennadouglasmw, brighty11, ceatau, chibblecons, chiltonchick333, christaslover, christmasangel, chuchkit, classicreebokss, clever_angel, cofi_shot, crazydiamond_, crunknwj, cuendillar, dashing_icons, daytripperkathy, deepbluesea3929, del_kaidin, dominatrixgrey, dragonlady981, ensue, eryslash, exotish, eyeconic, fa_hab_u_lous, fannishnej, fire_icons, floralcigarette, foreverred, frakalakalaka, garinungkadol, giles22_atl, going_x_crazy, haemorrhaging, happy_harper13, iloveorange_s, ilusionaryheart, innocentlyjaded, instantkarma19, ironjill, izzi_bo_bizzi, jane948, jeminigyrl, jewelles2, jubilli, khover, kirjava17, kyleia, lavenderfrost, lotsofjoy, love_higher_law, lufiamanaelf, luthien_black, m0836296, maelynesque, maytel, miyavist, mlledefer, monaiyra, murdericons, neikanshinigami, ninjitsu_x, noelanii, peaceinyou, peri0d, phantomberkanna, philosophimonki, pktrekgirl, punkprincessabz, sabersailor, sarah_eilonwy, september_nine, setine_kitsune, shirven, shoes_with_soul, sixminutesspare, sourdite, stab_arttodeath, stick, still_fading, svimmelhet, switch842, symm76, tash_pash, themeadow_song, theshizzness, tirwen_star03, toaster_phantom, truthfull_lies, ttiot, ubiquitous_girl, unmasked_icons, uozieaquely, wanderingbreeze, weasley_hobbit, weisy, xxjaybabyxx, zannah

Watched by (57):

_dennis_csi_, alina_crystal, angels_airwaves, arjd, babyblueprep, brennadouglasmw, brighty11, ceatau, chibblecons, chiltonchick333, cofi_shot, crazydiamond_, crunknwj, dashing_icons, daytripperkathy, deepbluesea3929, dominatrixgrey, dragonlady981, eyeconic, fa_hab_u_lous, fire_icons, floralcigarette, foreverred, frakalakalaka, garinungkadol, giles22_atl, happy_harper13, honeynougat, innocentlyjaded, instantkarma19, ironjill, jane948, kirjava17, kyleia, lavenderfrost, love_higher_law, m0836296, maelynesque, mlledefer, murdericons, naomi_baby, noelanii, odette_river, philosophimonki, pktrekgirl, sabersailor, sarah_eilonwy, shirven, shoes_with_soul, still_fading, svimmelhet, terrysmind, theshizzness, tirwen_star03, uozieaquely, wanderingbreeze, zannah

Advertisement

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…