Cross-posted from The Midnight Hour
In the same vein as yesterday's rant about doing the damn work, I thought I'd approach what I see as the single biggest difference between real writers and people who just like to call themselves writers for a variety of reasons. I call it discipline, but it's really something simpler. It's Doing It Every Day.
You absolutely cannot hope to come up consistently with a readable product if you don't write every day. You also can't expect your discipline to tide you over if you're not in the habit of doing it every day.The conventional wisdom is that it takes ninety days to make (or break) a habit, and habit is what your sitting-down-to-write must become.
Human beings are creatures of habit--I'd go so far as to say we specialize in it. It's such a powerful tool that we must be careful of it, and learn to use it consciously--or, I firmly believe, it will use us. Habit can be a best friend (when you're tired and you need some other motivation to sit down and bloody do the work) and worst enemy (when you've gotten into the surfing-for-just-a-few-minutes trap.)
I can't leave the question of habit without talking about timesuck. Timesuck is a habit run amok, something that keeps you from what you should be doing. My big timesucks are CatLOLs, Smart Bitches, and my f-list. (There. I've admitted it.) Easy bite-sized chunks of stuff that add up to hours per day--if I'm not careful.
There is a very simple, easy way to help a good habit settle in and keep a bad one in check. You can even buy it at the grocery store.
It's a kitchen timer. No, seriously.
I consider cheap, portable kitchen timers God's little gift to writers (along with commas and italic type, but that's another post.) Set it for a short amount of time and give your chosen timesuck your full attention. That way you won't feel deprived when it rings and you have to go back to working. Set it for a slightly longer time and write. No day is so busy you can't find ten minutes to write, and the timer relieves you of the responsibility of watching the clock. It also teaches you to sit down, cut out the sh!t, and produce.
But there's that critical component called Doing It Every Day. Sadly, there are no "tips" or "tricks" for this one. It must be sheer bloody-minded stubbornness. You have to want to do it, and want it badly enough that you will sit down and bloody well write even when you're tired, or not feeling well, or when you just don't want to do it again. The prospect of getting a paycheck motivates people to show up for their day jobs. You don't have that prospect in writing, really--or you have that prospect so infrequently as to be a laughable excuse for motivation. So the motivation to write has to come from somewhere else. I don't care where you find it, but you've got to find it somewhere or the whole experiment is doomed.
And you must, absolutely must, do it every day. Like anything else, writing demands practice. It's that practice that hones your craft. (Along with reading, but that's a different blog post.) Doing it every other day or once a week will not wash. If you do it every day, several things happen:
This last one is where my sticking-point is. Too many folks who call themselves writers allow other parts of their life to put writing on the back burner, and that cannot happen. They say they need quiet to work, and as soon as they get that quiet place they'll Produce A Masterpiece.
Bullsh!t. If you can't work with distractions going on around you, you're never going to make it as a writer. I work with two home-schooled kids under twelve underfoot all day, the doorbell ringing, phone calls, and a kid to drive to college three times a week. Plus there's errands, volunteering at the bookstore, cooking dinner, laundry, and a whole host of other things.
I figure I could work in one of those seventies-era movie newsrooms. You ever watch All The President's Men? Remember the phones ringing, people yelling, distraction pouring through the air? Yeah. Like that. If you do not exercise your ability to focus through those distractions, you won't make it. Your time to write will expand in proportion to the importance you attach to writing and the gods-honest priority you give it.
It really comes down to a simple question. Is writing important enough for you to make it a priority and spend the work and time to do it every day through the distractions? If it is, great, sit your butt down and do it. Set your timer. Chain yourself to your chair if that's what it takes.
If it's not, great. Find something else to do with your time. Gods bless you on your journey.
But please don't call yourself a writer. This is hard work, and if you're not going to do it...well, you don't need that title.
'Nuff said.
In the same vein as yesterday's rant about doing the damn work, I thought I'd approach what I see as the single biggest difference between real writers and people who just like to call themselves writers for a variety of reasons. I call it discipline, but it's really something simpler. It's Doing It Every Day.
You absolutely cannot hope to come up consistently with a readable product if you don't write every day. You also can't expect your discipline to tide you over if you're not in the habit of doing it every day.The conventional wisdom is that it takes ninety days to make (or break) a habit, and habit is what your sitting-down-to-write must become.
Human beings are creatures of habit--I'd go so far as to say we specialize in it. It's such a powerful tool that we must be careful of it, and learn to use it consciously--or, I firmly believe, it will use us. Habit can be a best friend (when you're tired and you need some other motivation to sit down and bloody do the work) and worst enemy (when you've gotten into the surfing-for-just-a-few-minutes trap.)
I can't leave the question of habit without talking about timesuck. Timesuck is a habit run amok, something that keeps you from what you should be doing. My big timesucks are CatLOLs, Smart Bitches, and my f-list. (There. I've admitted it.) Easy bite-sized chunks of stuff that add up to hours per day--if I'm not careful.
There is a very simple, easy way to help a good habit settle in and keep a bad one in check. You can even buy it at the grocery store.
It's a kitchen timer. No, seriously.
I consider cheap, portable kitchen timers God's little gift to writers (along with commas and italic type, but that's another post.) Set it for a short amount of time and give your chosen timesuck your full attention. That way you won't feel deprived when it rings and you have to go back to working. Set it for a slightly longer time and write. No day is so busy you can't find ten minutes to write, and the timer relieves you of the responsibility of watching the clock. It also teaches you to sit down, cut out the sh!t, and produce.
But there's that critical component called Doing It Every Day. Sadly, there are no "tips" or "tricks" for this one. It must be sheer bloody-minded stubbornness. You have to want to do it, and want it badly enough that you will sit down and bloody well write even when you're tired, or not feeling well, or when you just don't want to do it again. The prospect of getting a paycheck motivates people to show up for their day jobs. You don't have that prospect in writing, really--or you have that prospect so infrequently as to be a laughable excuse for motivation. So the motivation to write has to come from somewhere else. I don't care where you find it, but you've got to find it somewhere or the whole experiment is doomed.
And you must, absolutely must, do it every day. Like anything else, writing demands practice. It's that practice that hones your craft. (Along with reading, but that's a different blog post.) Doing it every other day or once a week will not wash. If you do it every day, several things happen:
* You give yourself the clearest possible signal that this work is not going to go away, and that you are committed to it.
* You bolster the habit of just sitting down and putting your hands to the effing keyboard.
* You give yourself the opportunity to practice hard enough and long enough to start producing readable product.
* You give your writing a priority to match other priorities in your life.
This last one is where my sticking-point is. Too many folks who call themselves writers allow other parts of their life to put writing on the back burner, and that cannot happen. They say they need quiet to work, and as soon as they get that quiet place they'll Produce A Masterpiece.
Bullsh!t. If you can't work with distractions going on around you, you're never going to make it as a writer. I work with two home-schooled kids under twelve underfoot all day, the doorbell ringing, phone calls, and a kid to drive to college three times a week. Plus there's errands, volunteering at the bookstore, cooking dinner, laundry, and a whole host of other things.
I figure I could work in one of those seventies-era movie newsrooms. You ever watch All The President's Men? Remember the phones ringing, people yelling, distraction pouring through the air? Yeah. Like that. If you do not exercise your ability to focus through those distractions, you won't make it. Your time to write will expand in proportion to the importance you attach to writing and the gods-honest priority you give it.
It really comes down to a simple question. Is writing important enough for you to make it a priority and spend the work and time to do it every day through the distractions? If it is, great, sit your butt down and do it. Set your timer. Chain yourself to your chair if that's what it takes.
If it's not, great. Find something else to do with your time. Gods bless you on your journey.
But please don't call yourself a writer. This is hard work, and if you're not going to do it...well, you don't need that title.
'Nuff said.
- Mood:
awake



Comments
A friend of mine always marvels that I can get so much done and still have time to write. I tell her it's a matter of priorities. I also have a very good husband who understands that I need my writing time. He still gets his time ;) As wives and mothers we have a lot of demands placed on us, so setting priorities with routine is how to get it done. That friend, btw, has started resetting her priorities to get back to writing.
And you're right about timesucks. I usually give myself a little time for those, but when I'm working on a project, I skim over my usual lurks and flisters just to see what's going on. I just don't say much because my mind is elsewhere.
I'm a freelance writer who mainly does copy for a tech website. I know what I have to write each day in order to make enough to pay the bills, and to make my goal for the year.
I'm at my desk every morning by 9 and write straight through until lunch. If I've been productive enough I'll do household projects in the afternoon, if not, I spend the afternoon writing.
When I get to putting the ideas down on paper for a story then the same discipline will apply.
I do have to occasionally say, "No, i can't do x with you right now, I need to write".
I didn't write much last week. I played a scene out in my head that doesn't even belong to a book I'm writing but which is necessary - to me - background material. I've also spent a fair amount of time traveling, including a journey involving sixteen hours, two taxis, two buses, two trains and one plane (plus some walking with 25kg of luggage), an international conference, lots of photography, a conference paper, a return journey that was almost as interesting as the one out (I wimped out, hired a car, and drove myself home at 2am) and various other antics...
...and I am a serious writer, too.
I get rather furious when someone suggests differently just because I don't conform to their ideal. Writers write. Writers produce stories. They don't produce them in the same manner and at the same rate, and someone who only picks up writing materials once every few months quite likely *isn't* serious, but I do know published writers who set back one day a week, and others who produce a book every few years, and they are writers, too. Darn good ones, some of them.
I equally know people who produce a lot of dribble every day. It's not the quantity. It's not what tools you use, what process, whether you outline, or what kind of stories you end up with.
Writers write. Everything else varies.
I have a small child under 2, two pets, a husband, and a constantly messy apartment. Are those excuses? No. Should I somehow find those elusive ten minutes to write anyway? Of course. But for me it's a very delicate balance between actually producing something that I can look back on and say "yes, lets keep that, it's worth it" and hammering out crap that I'll delete the next day--or hammering out nothing at all and feeling horribly guilty about it.
So here's the the pursuit of writing every day.
But of course, apparently I'm not a real writer --
I use my laptop exclusively for writing and when I tried to play a game on it the other night (kids were on the gaming computer), I couldn't do it. I ended up writing instead. >
I see why some have ruffled feathers over that sentence, but here's something for everyone to consider: one person gets up every day for 4 am practice, travels to competitions, swims laps until their muscles ache and goes on to medal in the Olympics. And another person can get in a pool without drowning, and perhaps even enjoys swimming recreationally.
But who is the "swimmer"?
Sure, it might be irritating for Person A to have Person B to also claim the title, but at the end of the day, only one of them has the medal to show for it.
I'm ruffled because for me the medals aren't the point, so I'm perfectly content to let someone else go home with them (and applaud them when they do!). But I'll be darned if that means I'm willing to let them talk down to me --or try and kick me out of the pool-- because they don't think I'm 'trying hard enough'.
I work full-time, go to grad-school half-time, have a "special- needs" pet plus 2 others, a husband, a house, etc, etc, but I still always find time for Timesuck. I need to eliminate the Timesuck! Your post did not offend me at all, I didn't read it as an attack but as the tough love I need. When I write every day I can actually see the improvement & the story is easier to get into after a short break than a long one & I am in a much better mood, too.
I write more days than not, but I ALWAYS find time for Timesuck. And that is going to change. I am taking the summer off grad school and I will use that time to finish my book & get it ready to query and I WILL do it.
THANK YOU.
I am having a hard time finding a polite response to this. While I applaud your dedication to your craft, I am rather taken aback at your rather brusque dismissal of those of us who don't meet your 'requirements' for Writer-hood.
Writers write. End of definition. Whether you approve or not, there are plenty of us out here who will go right on labeling ourselves as such. We write when we get the chance, or when the Muse strikes us-- on our own schedules and for our own enjoyment. We are no less 'writers' because we don't conform to someone else's preconceptions.
The problem with writing is that there are no good ways of carving the population up into easily labeled groups. There are simply too many ways to write, and for anyone to start trying to label them as 'good enough' and 'not good enough' is frankly rather insulting to those of us getting sorted.
You make the time to write. You do it because you have to because you have a deadline. You can't afford to wait for the "muse" to strike, you're the one striking the muse until she coughs up the goods.
Because for some of us writing is a job, a means of employment, and the difference between sleeping under a roof or sleeping in a box. :D It's not a hobby, it's not really for enjoyment (though it can be fun), and it's not something that we can do anything less than devote ourselves to everyday.
If it insults you, fine, why care what she thinks? *shrugs* It's not the end-all-be-all definition, it's just the opinion of some of us.
Edited at 2008-04-11 10:19 pm (UTC)
Working amid distraction is an acquired skill, one I've managed to un-acquire (dis-acquire? How about 'lose'?), now that I write at home full-time with no kids, just two very well-behaved animals and a moderately well-behaved husband.
But if I had your atmosphere, I'd learn to deal, because it's *that* important to me.
Which is ultimately your point, I think, not that we all have to do it the same way, but that we make it a priority. For most people, doing it every day is a signal to ourselves (and the world) that "YO! This is important!"
I turned in a book this morning. I'll be writing tonight. (OK, technically, reading a first draft so I can begin a rewrite tomorrow, but still...)
--Jeri Smith-Ready
Agreed.
I'm a 'speech is silver, silence is golden' sort of person, and my productivity increases substantially in the silence, but I have managed to train myself to work through noise and distraction and surprisingly it only took me a few weeks. I think there's only one disturbance I can't work through no matter how much I struggle and that's the baseline thumping of a subwoofer. Don't really know why, it's just one of those obnoxious, inexorable noises that gets straight into my brain.
I usually decide that when this noise starts up in the neighbourhood, it's time to watch a loud actiony film to drown it out or leave the house for a little while, instead of sitting around letting it frustrate me to the point where I can't work even when it stops. That's my compromise :)
I've found this to be true for me in other domains, too. If I'm reading a book, I read it straight through, no matter what. I'm not the kind of person who can read a chapter a night and work my way through something. In my non-writing life, I do psychological research, and if I'm designing an experiment or preparing a talk, or writing up my results for publication, I set aside huge chunks of time to do it, because in general, I do my best work when my thought process isn't interrupted. A lot of my colleagues prefer to do smaller amounts of work every day. Among the people I know, both methods have yielded great results.
None of this goes to say that "write every day" is bad advice- I think it's GREAT advice- and I think it's particularly good advice for people working on first novels. I just also think that there are individual differences, and that different people may need to practice their craft in different ways, using different schedules. I just wanted to say that if you try writing every day, and you find that it just doesn't work for you, I think that's okay, too, as long as you DO find a method that allows you to produce a good product on a consistent basis.
I firmly believe that other successful methods exist! I consider myself a serious writer who consistently produces readable product- I've published five books in the past two years, and I've got five more on the way. I see writing as a career, and I take it very seriously, but I also believe that part of developing your craft is discovering what works for YOU and what pushes YOU the most.
Thanks for the thought-provoking post, Lili!
-Jen Barnes
I think the point of your post - which is valid and I give a weary Amen of agreement to - that writing takes real commitment, sweat, and effort, was unfortunately diluted by the blanket statement of what makes someone a "real" writer. I'm sure out of the 100 members we have at Fangs, Fur and Fey, not all of them write every day. But all of them are writers, whether they earned that title by daily writing, weekly writing, weekend writing, or another method. And when that gets multiplied by writers with different work habits around the world, it doesn't seem feasible to say that daily writing is the only true way to be deemed a writer. Having a serious commitment toward writing is required, yes, but that doesn't always equate to daily writing.
That's how I took that "every day" statement. That if you're going to work this like a job ... work it like a job. Don't show up and say "eh, I don't feel like it" and just piddle around. Put your butt down and work. (write, edit, plot, read, whatever) Doing something for the writing every day that you're working.
Balance is obviously essential in life. *grins* Look at all those poor shmucks who go on vacation with their cellphones and laptops and answer calls from work when they're supposed to be enjoying the beach.
I think what it really boils down to is that for beginners (at least from my POV) putting your butt down and getting in the habit helps build a real dedication. Something that a lot of people seem to talk about trying to find.
I hear so many people say "I don't have time" or whatever excuse they can come up with. I've heard them all. I've used most of them myself. Then I pulled myself up by my bootstraps and wrote a novel in 60 days while going to work 50 hours a week, going to class another 10 hours, trying to keep my house clean, my laundry done, and my fridge in groceries. :D It can be done, and darn it I wrote every single day during those two months.
But more importantly, I wrote because I wanted to. I loved the story and loved seeing it unfold. It was worth the lack of sleep, the hectic lifestyle to do it.
Great post! Thank you. :)
For the first book, I was homeschooling, working PT, & doing single-mom stuff (my spouse travels a lot). Was I a writer? Yes.
So, after the first multi-book deal, I'm suddenly a FT writer. I still didn't write every single day.
Since I sold that first book, I've had a second 3-book contract, a manga series, and 2 anthologies. I STILL go weeks without writing a single word on paper. It's just not the right fit for me.
Personally, I don't believe that "writing" is simply the technical act of fingers on keys. Forcing words every day is counter-productive for me, but there's no doubt that I'm a writer.
Not all paths work for all people. Real writers write. Some do it every day; some do it in mad blurs after months of pondering (my method); and others squeeze it where they can around the business of living.
Melissa Marr
As I've said ad nauseum above, the long-term professional writer may have enough discipline that even when they're not "working" they're "working". But I very much view this discipline as fragile and the seduction of timesuck to be everpresent and very real.
The months of pondering is a discipline in and of itself, but often what new writers think is pondering is actually navel-gazing. The discipline of setting the timer and making writing a priority every day can help to make that pondering useful, and to differentiate between the pondering and the navel-gazing.
What do you think?
Do I write every day? Yeah--in one form or another. And I'm not sure if this is what Lilith meant, but this is how I take the advice. Write *something* It doesn't have to be the same project. You could be working on 3 or 4 different books, including a volume of short stories, a novella, and a book of poems. Change it up. But make an effort to get some type of text down that has a creative core to it. Something that isn't just an email or an application.
If you write within a genre like UF, staying on top of your game is hard work. You should read the stuff that you write, and experiment with different plots, and most importantly, keep banging out words. I don't work on the same novel every single day. But when I'm facing a deadline, I do try to get at least chapter done a week in bits and pieces. I'm always writing something--be it academic, UF, or some other genre. Switching it up keeps you from going crazy. But if you want to get better (or not get worse), you have to keep practicing.
I'm willing to acknowledge that there are all kinds of writers. But when Mercedes Lacky cranks out 3 novels/year (with her husband's help), and Laurel K Hamilton churns out the Anita Blake novels when she's got kids, then you have to admit that some writers are full-time and others are part-time. Yeah, the Anita Blake novels have suffered. But any series that long is going to falter, and Hamilton worked her ass off every day to get published and gain popularity.
If you write every other Sunday, then writing is your hobby. Every day or every other day, then it's your life. And if it's your life, then you'll probably keep knocking on editors' and agents' doors until you get published, because the alternative is walking around undead all the time.
If you're lucky enough to be able publish a piece here and there, and that makes you happy--awesome! You're not a full-time writer, and you don't need to be. If you consistently produce readable stuff because you really have no other choice, and feel like your current series could stretch to 12 books if only your editor just let you keep going...well, you're a lifer.
Another easy way to tell (and this will get me yelled at, but I get yelled at all the time): full-time writers often don't get their feathers ruffled because they feel like they may/may not fit into someone's proper writerly definition. They just know that they're writers, and so they work. Who has time to feel crappy when you're doing what you love?
- Jes Battis
By those terms, writing is NOT my life. . . actually, I knew that. No one thing could be my life. Parenting, frex, is extremely important to me, but I still have to have my career. Previously it was teaching; now it's writing.
Wait . . . by those terms writing is a hobby. Can we tell the IRS that? ;)
My feathers aren't ruffled on my behalf, but I do get ruffled by statements that can discourage other folks from doing this. Writers have enough self-doubt that adding to it isn't something I'm cool with . . . That's all. My whole response was to seek clarity & offer another perspective b/c it's a tough career to embark upon. I'm a fan of many paths in all things. The only set in stone writing belief for me (although I'm sure this too could be altered somehow) is that writers write. The rest is all subjective.
Melissa Marr
Have a lovely day! :-)
I looked at this post from a "you've got contracts and deadlines looming" and the best way not to kill yourself is to write a little bit every day. That way, you're not totally stressed trying to meet your deadlines. You meet them at a comfortable pace you set for yourself, and *fingers crossed sales are good* more contracts will be forthcoming.
While it's true that every author works differently (some will write the last half of their novel in a week and others will spread a novel out by writing a set word count every day until the book is finished) I imagine that for a lot of writers, the reality is somewhere in between. Life happens, interruptions can halt a steady pace, the muse stops talking, etc...so then we make up for it by blitz writing to get through and meet deadline.
And I can only do it by finding whatever process works best for me, rather than adhering to any set of absolute rules.
Edited at 2008-04-12 03:48 am (UTC)
So, instead of writing all the time, I devote four or five months to plotting, re-plotting and writing my latest novel. During those months I write my 2000-3000 words per day, every day, but I still allow normal life to go on.
I then spend around a month working on the first/second/third draft with my editor (including all rewrites), another month in tidy-ups, and by then it's November so I spend a month on NanoWrimo to get 50k words of the NEXT novel down.
Finally, at the start of December, I pack away the writing part of my brain and start getting the house ready for the annual christmas do with the whole family.
I may jot down plot ideas, but I usually don't start writing again until April/May.
I guess it's like farming - letting a field lie fallow gives it time to recharge for the next crop.
I'm not saying my way is better, just that a few months of intense effort with a defined goal at the end (edited, publishable novel) appeals to me far more than working away with, perhaps, no defined end in sight.