Hello, everyone,
Last night I found an online site that had reviewed a piece of mine. It was not a terribly favorable review, and they made a snarky comment about my choice of title. The latter part upset me the most because I didn't choose the title, and actually found the editor's choice horrifying.
The site is a blog style review site, that allows readers to comment. I signed up last night and was going to reply to the review, making sure to set the record straight about the title choice and some other factors of my story. But then I stopped myself, afraid it was one of those bad 2am decisions.
So I'm just wondering, is it ever a good time to reply to a criticism? I figured saying something about an editor that could be perceived as a negative, even though I probably won't work for her again, probably wasn't a good idea. Plus I expect it would come off whiny and just open me up for more criticism.
Has anyone every replied, either in their own blog or through an email or letter to a criticism of their work? Thanks for any thoughts or advice you can share.
~
Last night I found an online site that had reviewed a piece of mine. It was not a terribly favorable review, and they made a snarky comment about my choice of title. The latter part upset me the most because I didn't choose the title, and actually found the editor's choice horrifying.
The site is a blog style review site, that allows readers to comment. I signed up last night and was going to reply to the review, making sure to set the record straight about the title choice and some other factors of my story. But then I stopped myself, afraid it was one of those bad 2am decisions.
So I'm just wondering, is it ever a good time to reply to a criticism? I figured saying something about an editor that could be perceived as a negative, even though I probably won't work for her again, probably wasn't a good idea. Plus I expect it would come off whiny and just open me up for more criticism.
Has anyone every replied, either in their own blog or through an email or letter to a criticism of their work? Thanks for any thoughts or advice you can share.
~
14 comments | Leave a comment
