Home

Advertisement

 
 
15 April 2008 @ 02:24 pm
S2R1 - results  

Unfortunately we have to say goodbye to 2 talented icon makers, I hope you'll stick around the community and join the next sessions!

Is anyone willing to make banners for this round?? If so please let me know... thanks! 

ELIMINATED 



[info]bluesuzanne 
- with 10 negative votes.... I'm so sorry! Better luck next time :)

and...



[info]allllure - with 8 negative votes... I'm sorry! Better luck next time! :)



PEOPLE'S CHOICE



[info]hpnarnia - with 7 positive votes, congrats!



MOD'S CHOICE



[info]loving_w - the colouring is great :)



TALLIES
12345
678910
img120/4126/emiliederavin858ksf0.png
1112131415

icon # - negative (x) // positive (o)
01 - x x x x x
02 - x // o o
03 - x x x // o
04 - x // o
05 - o o o o o
06 - x x x
07 - x x x x x x x x
08 - no votes
09 - x x x x // o
10 - o o o o o o o
11 - o o o o
12 - o o
13 - x x x x x x x
14 - o o o o o
15 - x x x x x x x x x x

COMMENTS
Please comment to this post with your icon # if you'd like to get your comments, thanks!!

Round 2 will be posted asap!

Tags: ,
 
 
( Post a new comment )
loving_w: Scarlett again[info]loving_w on April 15th, 2008 12:38 pm (UTC)
Thank so much for MC! :)
#11 please)
::giulia::[info]para_giaulz on April 17th, 2008 09:09 pm (UTC)
you're welcome!

POSITIVE:
11-- It's not to dark or to light
#11 -- very pretty coloring, it could have more exciting composition, but the image wasn't easy to colorize and I'm impressed
#11 - it's a very nicely executed icon and I like the way her hair appears to sparkle
#11 -- lovely coloring and crop
Tove[info]tove_91 on April 15th, 2008 01:28 pm (UTC)
Could I have comments for icon 5 please?^^
::giulia::: beyonce - ch 26[info]para_giaulz on April 17th, 2008 09:11 pm (UTC)
SURE

POSITIVE:
#05 -- The text on the icon fits perfectly, it's not sloppy, it's just perfect.
#05 -- Simple and nice. Good placement of text.
#05 -- brave and interesting cropping, the text is not too conspicuous and fits in very well
#05 -- the whole concept is well done
#05 -- Great cropping and use of contrast with the b/w image. The text is also placed wonderfully.
Deniz: milo and masi[info]hpnarnia on April 15th, 2008 01:35 pm (UTC)
Wow! Thank you! Can I have comments for 10?
::giulia::: beyonce - hot stuff![info]para_giaulz on April 17th, 2008 09:13 pm (UTC)
POSITIVE:
#10 -- Good coloring.
#10 -- The simplicity makes this icon beautiful.
10-- The cropping is very good.
#10 -- It's simple but very pretty
#10 -- nice, soft coloring and interesting cropping
#10 -- Awesome color.
#10 -- Simple and clear, great coloring.
Littleton - Pace[info]wunderkinddd on April 15th, 2008 02:04 pm (UTC)
Comments for Nine, please :D
::giulia::: drop it like it's hot[info]para_giaulz on April 17th, 2008 09:15 pm (UTC)
NEGATIVE:
#09 -- The brush is way too overpowering.
#09 -- the text is overpowering the soft small image
#09 -- the font looks too "grungy" for a pretty Emilie photo
#09 -- The coloring is too bright and the text does not fit in

POSITIVE:
#09 -- i love how the icon maker placed the wording in the corner. the font is really cute too.
allllure[info]allllure on April 15th, 2008 02:17 pm (UTC)
#7 please?
::giulia::: emile - free[info]para_giaulz on April 17th, 2008 09:17 pm (UTC)
NEGATIVE:
#07 -- The texture is not well used and the face is a bit yellow.
#07 -- The icon is too dark, the texture doesn't fit with the icon and it could have needed something extra as it just seems too empty.
#07 -- The coloring and the texture don't compliment eachother.
#07 -- It's a bit too blurry and texture doesn't fit.It looks so yellow.
#07 -- The cropping is very unprofitable
#07 -- Colorig is too yellow.
#07 -- in some places the icon looks too blurred and in others it looks to sharp
#7 -- I don't like how her face nearly blends in with the background.
Karin: LOST - Michelle[info]own_world on April 15th, 2008 02:34 pm (UTC)
I'd like comments for 13
::giulia::: emile lims[info]para_giaulz on April 17th, 2008 09:20 pm (UTC)
NEGATIVE:
#13 -- The picture isn't well cropped and the brush/texture doesn't fit with the icon.
#13 -- The textures don't mesh very well, the icon is very bland.
#13 -- It looks like no coloring has been done and I'm not fond of the crop
#13 - the crop is awkward, partly because of the streak of red at her neck. Also the little dots just seem messy.
#13 -- Bad crop and brush use.
#13 -- Unoriginal cropping. Also the red light on her neck is out of place.
#13 -- The brush doesn't look so nice on this one.
Tina: [celeb] evangeline lilly[info]fan_cifully on April 15th, 2008 02:51 pm (UTC)
#3 please :)
::giulia::: gimme more icons[info]para_giaulz on April 17th, 2008 09:22 pm (UTC)
NEGATIVE:
03 -- It's very dark
#03 -- The image is too dark.
#03 -- the icon is too dark

POSITIVE:
#03 -- The effects fit with the picture and the text is placed on the perfect place
ashonmy on April 15th, 2008 07:15 pm (UTC)
comments of icon 1 please?
::giulia::: I got troubles - xtina[info]para_giaulz on April 17th, 2008 09:24 pm (UTC)
NEGATIVE:
#01 -- The text throws everything off, if it were textless, it'd be more fitting.
01 -- To dark
#01 - the font is heavy and distracting and the blending of the face in the background is messily done. Also the whole thing lacks contrast
#01 -- the blending is not well done and the text is too dark
#01 -- The grunge texture doesn't fit with the icon and the placement of the text is distracting from the actual main point.
[info]evening_road on April 16th, 2008 02:06 am (UTC)
#6? Thanks! :)
::giulia::: lindsay cig[info]para_giaulz on April 17th, 2008 09:25 pm (UTC)
NEGATIVE:
#06 -- It's a bit too blurry and texture doesn't fit.
#06 -- Bad light texture use.
#06 -- the lights don't fit the icon.
bluesuzanne[info]bluesuzanne on April 16th, 2008 02:30 am (UTC)
could i have the comments please, thanks
::giulia::: save me from myself[info]para_giaulz on April 17th, 2008 09:27 pm (UTC)
NEGATIVE:
#15 -- The colors (green,pink) used do not fit with picture, it seems a little bit weird
#15 -- The coloring is not very good and it's overall too dark.
15-- The coloring is too green
#15 -- it could use a texture in the background, the crop is already plain; also the colors are a bit oversaturated
#15 -- Emilie looks way too yellow to me.
#15 -- It's so yellow.
#15 -- the coloring is very unprofitable as it's giving Emilie a slightly sick look
#15 -- the colour on the texture doesn't fit the image at all and why is her hair red?
#15 -- I don't like the coloring of this icon.
#15 -- her hair is purple... and the background color is too off, to fit the icon.
 

Advertisement