peacelovehappy ([info]peacelovehappy) wrote in [info]chalice_circle,
@ 2008-02-11 12:37:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
The End of YRUU?
Steering Commitee has sent out <lj-cut text="this letter:">

"Dear Unitarian Universalist Youth,

As the continental YRUU Steering Committee, it is with
great sorrow, that we inform you that on June 30, 2008, the UUA will
cease to fund the YRUU youth leadership at the continental level.
Therefore, there will no longer be having Youth Council, this summer
or years following, and the work of youth ministry within the UUA will
shift to a congregationally based focus.
This change has been in the works for several years. At
the Long-Range Planning Meeting in 2003, between YRUU and the UUA,
"Common Ground III" was proposed. Common Ground III stated that
further goal setting and re-imagining of youth ministry and YRUU was
needed. The name Common Ground comes from two meetings in the early
1980's that dissolved Liberal Religious Youth (LRY) and created Young
Religious Unitarian Universalists (YRUU). At Youth Council 2004
consensus on the resolution of Common Ground III was blocked, at which
point the UUA Board of Trustees convened the Consultation to and with
Youth on Youth Ministry culminated with the Summit on Youth Ministry
in July 2007. This summit resulted in the Youth Ministry Working Group
comprised of UUA staff, and volunteers, three of which are youth. The
working group has been tasked with implementing the objectives
outlined in the Summary Report on Ministry to and with Youth.

However, youth programming on the district and
congregational levels will continue. YRUU Steering Committee will now
be advocating for a strong continental youth leadership body that will
be empowered to direct the youth office with the goal of serving
congregations. We will also be advocating for the growth of
anti-racism/anti-oppression work within youth ministry. This will
include support for the Groundwork collective of trainers, DRUUMM
YaYA, and future identity-based youth and young adult ministries.

As representatives of the larger UU youth community, we
value feedback, and will be setting up a blog for that purpose.
Thoughts, memories, rants, and love notes are appreciated and
welcomed.

In Faith,

YRUU Steering Committee"  </lj-cut>

    My first reaction was sadness and the urge to write a long letter about how important YRUU has been to my life and to the lives of many people I care about, and to send this letter to... everybody, to Bill Sinkford, Gini Courter, steering committee, the youth office, the board....
and I may still do that, however upon some reflection (and reading some other people's well thought out reactions)  perhaps that is not the correct course of action.  YRUU was, and still is in many ways, a huge part of my life, the experiences I had, the people I met, and the things I learned through YRUU have shaped who I am in a way that nothing else in my life has.  I have seen it as a community that can save lives, a place where people who feel like outcasts everywhere else can find acceptance, and where important issues can be brought out in the open for discussion.  For me it has been a place to meet people from accross the country, to examine my place in the world, to talk about big issues like racism in an open way, a place where I felt not only accepted, but in charge, like I could actually do something.  I have forged many of my strongest ties through YRUU.   The thought of YRUU not existing to provide the so dearly needed services to current and future youth saddens my like little else.  But I do not think letter writing will help, except perhaps for personal catharsis.  the decision has been made and it is up to us to make the best of it.  One of my major problems is that when common ground 1 happened, there was a common ground 2, LRY was disbanded, but YRUU was created, what creation is coming out of this decision?  will there be a common ground 4 creating a new youth organization?  or will YRUU just be expected to exist without funding?  now I know that the UUA is only cutting funding to contenental stuff (steering commitee, youth council etc.) but it is a symbolic disowning of all of YRUU. 
    not that YRUU is perfect, far from it, my time working on both district and continental YRUU stuff showed me that, but it has a valuble role that must be filled by something in its absence.  YRUU may not be doing its job properly, but neither are our congregations, there is little support in our congregations for youth and even less for young adults, and while the consultation on ministry to and with youth, many actions on the part of Bill Sinkford, the UUA board, and steering commitee are trying to put the focus on congregations their efforts are not working.  Removing funding from YRUU will not encourage churches to better support their youth, it will simply eliminate part of the one place youth are supported.  as someone who went to church every sunday, and genuinly ejoyed it, it wasn't the same as YRUU, I liked church, I liked youth group, but I loved cons.  church made me feel warm, it wrapped me up in singing and poetry, but it didn't make me do anything, it didn't make me reconsider my place in the world, it didn't make me step outside my comfort zone, it didn't put me in leadership positions, it didn't let me run worship, it didn't let me stay up untill 3am discussing religion and politics, it didn't provide me with oppurtunities to run workshops,  or a network of people that span the country.  YRUU did. 
    But the question we need to be asking ourselves is not what can we do to get the UUA to change its mind, but what can we do to make youth programming better? why was YRUU not benifiting the UUA? why arn't our churches supporting our youth? and, most importantly, what can we do to change it?  I fully understand the outcry this will cause (reminds me of the outcry after con con was cancelled, except on a much larger scale) but I want to propose that instead of getting extreamly angry we try and create something new.  if you're mad that youth arn't being supported, do something about it!  if you're upset that this may cause the end of YRUU, that conferences will ceice, make sure they don't!  talk to your district youth steering commitee, talk to your congregations, talk to your friends, clearly something is wrong in our faith and getting our money back is not the issue. the issue is that youth and young adults are not supported by our religion, that UU youth often don't think they have a religion or don't associate with unitarian universalism, that our faith grows not from educating and keeping youth involved, but through converting unhappy middle aged white middle class americans, that our churches are not a welcoming place for many who could get so much from our faith, that people burn out (the fact that most of the youth who were extreamly involved in UUism with me have since become frustrated and uninvolved or have left the faith all together).  Our religion is supposed to be about acceptance, about support and community, but folks, we are failing.  If we cannot even support our own youth, how can we expect to change the rest of the world?  if our own youth do not identify with us, how can we expect to grow?  if we cannot change, how can we expect to survive? 

this is just my jumbled up thoughts as of right now.  this is coming from a white, female, young adult, who is a life-long UU, a person who was involved in congregational affairs, choir, RE, youth group, district YRUU, DYSC, youth programming at Ferry Beach, youth trip to transylvania, continental YRUU, and GA; someone who has sat through countless hours of meetings about youth stuff on every level, who has left meetings in tears, who has spent more time working on UU things than anything else pritty much, who has been to trainings and workshops galore, who can spout acronyms like no other.  I do not mention these things to sound cocky, but just to illustrate how much of an impact a decision like this would have had on my life if it had been made just 6 years earlier, I would be a completely different person, and I do not think in a good way.  I, for a time, embodied what the UUA board is saying youth should be, I was involved on all levels, I had a supportive congregation with a strong youth group, but that wasn't what made the biggest impact on me, even that left me wanting something else, something else that was almost fulfilled by YRUU, but not intirely, we need something else, we need creation and not distruction.  I have read some interesting opinions already, but I would be interested in hearing what everyone else has to say.

in faith and struggle,
Flo




(Post a new comment)


[info]mo_hair
2008-02-12 12:06 am UTC (link)
i am a convert to uu, and have been involved in teaching church school (particularly owl) for many years now. i entirely agree with you. were i a youth right now i would interpret this a slap in the face! now, your post is the first i've heard of this change, so there may be more to this situation, but my first reaction is essentially anger. we have a constant discussion in our church about how to retain our youth and this seems like an abandonment of that cause. on one hand the uua has put time and money into advertising and drawing in new members, and on the other they are failing to keep our current youth and young adults involved. none of this makes sense to me, esp since our yruu program has been SO successful and always well attended.

/rant. now i'm off to find out more info. about this :-(

(Reply to this)


[info]desertrose68
2008-02-12 12:52 am UTC (link)
is this specific to your church or to the whole UUA in general?

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]peacelovehappy
2008-02-12 06:53 am UTC (link)
this is the whole UUA, all that is being disbanded is continental YRUU, but that will tricle down to the districts and churches.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]newtonsenigma
2008-02-12 01:41 am UTC (link)
This is certainly not a new thing, but has sure felt not very transparent.

I'm a youth advisor in the SWD and although our congregational youth program is doing very well, the re-visioning process at the continental level seems unfair and quite top-down.

All-in-all, I think it is up to the congregations to make YRUU successful so maybe removing the UUA will actually help force a change.

(Reply to this)


[info]newtonsenigma
2008-02-12 01:59 am UTC (link)
http://www25.uua.org/YRUU/governance/ycresolutionarchive/yc07.htm#4

If you read the YRUU Response to the YRUU Question (of the Summit on Youth Ministry), it seems clear there is a real desire to keep something like YRUU at the continental level.

The YRUU steering committee should make the decision-making process transparent so it can be examined.

(Reply to this)


[info]kamamamama
2008-02-12 03:32 am UTC (link)
I wonder if this is related to the recent derecognition of a lot of affiliated groups? If you want details I am afraid I deleted the conversation, but on my UU-buddhist list a few months ago there was intensive discussion about the UUA (the board?) deciding to no longer recognize most of the affiliate groups, UUbuddhists but also CUUPS and many, many other groups.

(Reply to this)


[info]phoam909
2008-02-12 03:56 am UTC (link)
I stayed in the church because of YRUU. Perhaps the time has come for a UU youth organization that doesn't fall under the UUA? Maybe...

(Reply to this)


[info]trusting_fool
2008-02-12 04:19 am UTC (link)
I am a relatively young young adult who was involved in district level YRUU programming but no higher beyond attending GA once. I agree with much of what you said. Additionally, I do see the need to revamp/restructure YRUU--many of the communities I was in, while lively, were not entirely healthy for the youth involved. Our leaders were either really involved and ended up burning out or didn't do enough and there was no in between. In my district, I saw the atmosphere at conferences get more and more sexual and uncomfortable. I saw a lot of problems from where I was standing, and I'm sure there were more at the continental level that I didn't follow very closely.

I also agree that the youth need to be supported. I don't know what the answer is, but I hesitate to insist that we need a replacement organization, because we tried a replacement organization once and it didn't work. Perhaps the UUA could direct its funding to district and congregational support of youth, offering grants for churches to hire Youth Programs Coordinators, thereby funding a more bottom-up approach to youth support. As for where to go in the long term, I think that while the UUA's support of youth is imperative, a continental youth leadership structure is not. Maybe, just maybe, if the UUA encourages congregational support of youth in an effective way that includes financial as well as informational resources and support, a new continental structure will eventually be created BY THE YOUTH.

Sometimes, top-down works. Here in Boston, First Church decided they wanted to support young adults, so they put forth funding and hired someone to start a group. That first coordinator worked really hard, and BUUYA (Boston UU Young Adults) has been going strong for two and a half (three and a half?) years now. But sometimes, bottom-up works just as well. Those of us who are most active in Boston have gotten together and are probably going to get ourselves a paid young adult facilitator for the Mass Bay District starting this next fiscal year. I think the difference between these two is that the top-down method happened on the congregational level, and the bottom-up method happened at the district level. That's why I think that if the UUA helps congregations support youth and create healthy youth programming, the youth will, in turn, create a healthy and sustainable continental leadership structure.

But we'll see what happens next.

(Reply to this)


[info]firstlilies
2008-02-12 03:00 pm UTC (link)
Frankly, my involvement (as a youth) with YRUU was short-lived because of what I saw as a serious need of revamping. We worked on this in our own, but found going any higher than that impossible.

I'm hoping this is finally the long-needed response and have many hopes for what may be the results.

I highly doubt the UUA has any plans to abandon its youth and I'm sure (from what I'm reading) that this is simply a temporary dismantling so that something better can be built.

(Reply to this)


[info]triadruid
2008-02-12 09:37 pm UTC (link)
Thank you for forwarding the letter, but can you fix your LJ-cut?

(Reply to this)


[info]ferndalealex
2008-02-13 02:55 pm UTC (link)
the UUA will
cease to fund the YRUU youth leadership at the continental level.


I'd like to suggest (as I did in the other thread) that they simply pulled funding for this organization. It sounds like the organization could continue to operate independently if they choose. What kind of alternate funding could be available?

What ways can be imagined to continue a continental organization without UUA dollars?

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]sarahtalia
2008-02-16 06:45 am UTC (link)
Easy: there are plenty of youth and young adults who believe YRUU is the lifeblood of the church. Plenty of them have jobs now. Hire a fundraiser on commission the first time, and with that $ hire a full-time fundraiser. These are more dedicated than any alumni on earth. Most churches are just pouring $ into youth and young adults and our ridiculous Association has their heads in the sand. Our denomination is the second richest in the nation. Believe me, there is $ to be had for the asking.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…