donnaidh_sidhe ([info]donnaidh_sidhe) wrote in [info]cf_feminist,
@ 2006-03-01 17:11:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
I'm here because I've recently become quite disappointed in another feminist community that I was beginning to rather like. Basically, a CF friend of mine got jumped on by a mother because my friend protested that the way the mods kickbanned a CFer who said why she was CF was way too harsh, even though the CFer definitely put her foot in it. The mods did not reprove the person who jumped on my friend, even though said person resorted to looking over my friend's userinfo and used that info for an ad hominem attack.

When I asked about whether the person who attacked my friend was going to be reprimanded, the banning mod told me that the person who attacked my friend was right in her comment (she said my friend, because of being childfree, was not equipped to judge what is offensive about a statement). When I asked about what the other mods thought, I got no reply. My friend says that there has also been no reply to the e-mail she sent the mods.

I find myself at a loss, here. Before that drama, I was feeling pretty okay in that community. After this correspondence, I find myself believing that it is only okay to be a childfree feminist if you know your place. That means don't talk about being childfree unless you absolutely have to; don't show you are proud about being childfree because then you are saying that being a parent is something bad and it'll get your ass handed to you; to don't ever even think of saying that being childfree is better for you than being a parent, because a parent may take offence that you are denigrating their family status; don't speak about social or institutional discrimination against childfree women unless you are absolutely sure to show the ways how mothers are discriminated against, as well.

All of the above, I never really thought about until this past week. Now I know to shut my metaphorical mouth about being childfree unless I'm in a space that is actually safe for me, not one that merely purports to be.



(Post a new comment)


[info]princsscybermob
2006-03-08 12:04 am UTC (link)
Although I don't know the circumstances, I sure can understand that you are frustrated for being treated badly because of being childless by choice. I know that I often choose my words very carefully or don't mention it at all.

(Reply to this)


[info]lookintomyeyes
2006-06-29 04:17 pm UTC (link)
I am a professional, I chose to be one, and because i actually want to use my degree, I have chosen not to have children for at least 10 years, if not more. I tell people that when they start to pester me that I'm "going to be popping out little bambinos ina few years". I am also agaisnt daycares, which pisses ALOT of people off.
However, when I speak about my choice (which is often) I also try and not piss parents off by explaining the other half to my coin. It may not apply to you, but this is it:
I had a stay at home mom for 12 years of my life. She taught me (self)discipline, how to share, and cared for me. Because I choose to be a professional, having kids would put them (in what I feel is) in an disadvantage state, as I could nto properly care for them. So the baseline is: I respect others who have kids, but I also realize that raising, taking care of them, does not have a place in my life.


...and then I tell them to go to hell if they still pester me about wanting kids eventually. :P

(Reply to this)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…