Curtana ([info]curtana) wrote in [info]bstg_icontest,
@ 2007-08-04 10:55:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Entry tags:best of the month

The Best of the Month returns!
In our User Info there's a section about Best of the Month voting. I have no idea how long it's been since the community actually did this - I know it hasn't been done since I joined, at the very least! Well, [info]miravisu and I would like to revive it, though in a slightly different form.

Our current idea is that, in the non-spoiler category, the winning First Place icons for the past four challenges will automatically be eligible for the award, which should give us a minimum of eight icons to choose from (more in the case of ties for first place). Since there are only half as many spoiler icons, the Best of the Month voting for Challenge 3 would only take place every eight challenges instead of every four.

We hope that this will work well, especially as there's very little extra time and effort involved on your parts - just one extra round of voting every month or two, and the chance of an extra-shiny banner for the winner :) If everything goes well, we would also like to do a Best of the Year vote, picking from the past Best of the Month winners, but that's far in the future so we won't worry about it too much quite yet!

Does this sound good to everyone? Anyone forsee any problems that we need to address before we begin? I hope it will be fun for everyone to recognize and celebrate some of the very best icons that our members have created!



(Post a new comment)


[info]arlet33
2007-08-04 03:55 pm UTC (link)
That sounds like a great idea. I'm all for it.

The only thing I can see is that we only run two contests a month, so that would give us 4 icons to vote on for the non-spoiler challenges. Unless we're going to do best of two months for the non-spoiler challenge and best of 4 months for the spoiler challenge. Either was is cool with me.

(Reply to this)(Thread)

Re: BOTM coverage
[info]miravisu
2007-08-04 05:06 pm UTC (link)
*nods*
You have a good point. This was something that worried me at first too, on how to make BOTM work since we don't exactly have loads of challenges each month compared to other icontest communities that actually may have several for each week in fact.

But as [info]curtana wrote above:
"the winning First Place icons for the past four challenges will automatically be eligible for the award"


In other words we'll have a slightly modified BOTM process.. the alternative would be that we name this "best of" vote something differently, since don't do this voting on a pure monthly basis and some might find it overly confusing. Hopefully we'll get more opinions on the matter though! Do you find this an odd BOTM setup?

As at the moment the idea is that Best of The Month will always apply to the four most recent contests, whether they were in the same calendar month or not. So it's more focus on the month for voting, than the months in question that the four most recent contest weeks were done :)

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]curtana
2007-08-04 07:11 pm UTC (link)
Yeah, I should have made it clearer that I didn't expect that it would ever really correspond to calendar months :) We could change the name to something less confusing, perhaps - 'Best of the Best' or 'Grand Prize' or something, maybe?

(Reply to this)(Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…