I am putting up the results a little bit early because there is an issue with one of the images. However, we have the normal amount of votes we normally do, so I feel certain ending voting now.

The person leaving us this week is:
lwena11
- 7 votes
I can't show the image because this is the image that we're having a problem with. Looks like maybe someone hacked imageshack? Yikes.

Sorry to see you go - definitely hang around for voting and the comeback round!

And the good news!

People's Choice:
Tie!

by scifi_tv_addict

and


by xtitania

Mod's Choice:

by callmelydia

( Tally )

As always, comment with your icon number if you'd like to hear your comments.

Also, don't forget, Challenge 5 is already up for you guys to work on! There will be NO extension this week, so don't anticipate one!

While voting is going on for Challenge 4, I am putting up the new images. You may use any or all of these images for your icon:

( Kara & Leoben )

Submit your icon as a comment to this post. Your icons are due Sunday July 19th by midnight EST. There will be absolutely NO extension, so don't anticipate on!

It's time to vote. Four people did not enter and had no skips remaining, so they are unfortunately eliminated: justlikemars, starspank, vordogh and xmaidelx. Also, a few people did not enter and are using their skips: benelie, green_queen, greyfable, iladora, theastolat. Yikes, that's a lot.

Since so many people did not enter this week, we are only going to be eliminating one person this week.

Now on to the voting - Please comment with your 2 least favorite icons, including reasons WHY. Please be specific - "coloring" isn't good enough, for example. Also, please leave preference out of it. You may not like icons with a lot of open space, but that doesn't make it a bad icon - just not one for you. I reserve the right to not count a vote if I feel like it is based on personal preference. Also, please vote for your one favorite icon - a reason why is not necessary but is appreciated. And, of course, do not vote for yourself.

( Cut for the icons )

Sorry this is late - I've been a bit scatterbrained this week!

Voting is now over, which means two people are leaving us:


by _goingtralala
- 12 votes

and


by acari
- 12 votes

Thank you so much for participating! Sorry to see you go and I hope you stick around for voting and also a Comeback Round somewhere down the line!

And the good news!

People's Choice:

by scifi_tv_addict
+ votes

Mod's Choice:

by nowgold
Excellent text choice!

( Cut for the tally )

As always, if you would like to hear your comments, comment with your icon number and I'll get back to you.

And remember, Challenge 4 is already up and due Wednesday!

Sorry this is late. It's time to vote. Two people did not enter and had no skips remaining, so they are unfortunately eliminated: daniisupernova, far_to_nowhere. Also, a few people did not enter and are using their skips: benelie, justlikemars, radon_, starspank.

Now on to the voting - Please comment with your 3 least favorite icons, including reasons WHY. Please be specific - "coloring" isn't good enough, for example. Also, please leave preference out of it. You may not like icons with a lot of open space, but that doesn't make it a bad icon - just not one for you. I reserve the right to not count a vote if I feel like it is based on personal preference. Also, please vote for your one favorite icon - a reason why is not necessary but is appreciated. And, of course, do not vote for yourself.

( Voting )

Also, don't forget Challenge 4 is already up and due next Wednesday.

I've extended the deadline for Challenge 3 until tomorrow morning. In the meantime, I am putting up the image for Challenge 4.

( Challenge 4: Laura Roslin )

Enter your icon as a comment to this post. Your icon is due next Wednesday by July 8th by 11:59 PM EST.

Voting for Challenge 2 is now over, and it is time to lose two more people. It was VERY close this one! The two people leaving us are:


by collswan
- 13 votes

and



by icedteainthebag
- 8 votes

Thanks so much for participating! And please stick around because we ARE going to do a Comeback Challenge somewhere down the line.

And now, the good news!

People's Choice:

by radon_
+ 5 votes

Mod's Choice:

by splodge04

( Cut for the tally )

As always, if you would like to hear your comments, please comment with your icon number.

And don't forget, Challenge 3 is already up and due in a week

While voting is going on for Challenge 2, I am going to put up the images for Challenge 3.

( Felix Gaeta )

Submit your icon as a comment to this post. Your icon is due Sunday June 28th by 11:59 PM EST.

Challenge 2 is now closed and it is time to vote. A few people did not enter and had no skips remaining, so they are eliminated: likegunfire, overreact andprettybutt. Also, a few people did not enter, so they will be using their skips: acari, daniisupernova, ender839, far_to_nowhere, nicole_anell, vordogh and xmaidelx. That's a lot. :(

Now on to the voting - Please comment with your 3 least favorite icons, including reasons WHY. Please be specific - "coloring" isn't good enough, for example. Also, please leave preference out of it. You may not like icons with a lot of open space, but that doesn't make it a bad icon - just not one for you. I reserve the right to not count a vote if I feel like it is based on personal preference. Also, please vote for your one favorite icon - a reason why is not necessary but is appreciated. And, of course, do not vote for yourself.

( Cut for voting )

First of all, I just sent out mid-week reminders to everyone who has yet to enter Challenge 2, which is due Thursday by 11:59 PM EST. So get on that :)

Also, I want to hear your opinion on something. During Round 3, the first Round of bsg_lims I ran, I had a comeback round. If you had been voted out or dropped out up to that point (usually at the midway point) there was a challenge where one person could get back in the competition.

Now, let me offer you the pros and cons on this:

Pros:
Everyone has a suck icon every now and then ;) And sometimes, good iconers get out on the rare bad icon. This gives people a second chance. Also, sometimes people have to drop out because of time issues and what not.

Cons:
It gives that person who gets voted back in kind of a free pass. If they got voted out Challenge 1 and come back Challenge 10, they skipped a whole lot of challenges they really didn't have to work for.

So I would like to know, and will likely go with the consensus on this:

Poll #1416259 Comeback Round
Open to: All, detailed results viewable to: All

Should we have a comeback round?