I'm not sure what I am thinking right now. I just watched the newest episode of Bones,
The He in the She and I really liked it. Normally I dislike shows that parade the idea of a transgender character as a novelty, oddity. This episode didn't do that, at least to my way of thinking.
Warning: the following paragraphs will discuss the plot of this episode in depth, as well as the ideas of redemption, transformation, and change. Please do not read if you haven't seen the episode, for there will be spoilers.
The first time I saw a transgender character on TV, I was watching CSI. It was all the way back in the first season of the original show; I was young (still in high school), watching in my parents bedroom. The character I am referring to, of course, is Paul Milander (sp?), the villain that Grissom spent many episodes chasing in that first season. The big reveal of Paul Milander' "TRUE" sex was in the last episode of the 1st season, and it was hinted (rather, mostly explicitly stated) that this was the source of the killer's insanity. This episode turned my stomach and I stopped watching CSI. (Sidenote: the fanfiction story
Nicky got me slightly interested in CSI again, but I couldn't watch the show, so I submerged myself in the fan fiction for at least a week).
At this time I'd never been exposed to the idea of transgenderism, transexuality, or the more colloquial terms hermaphedites/transvestites. My first impression of people transitioning was the idea that people who transition are mental patients, which I know today is wrong.
I'm not going to bore you with a rendition of all the different episodes throughout television history where gender and sexuality are used as "surprise" endings, as "twists" to various criminal shows. It happens often enough for it not to be noteworthy. Instead, I'm going to jump straight to the episode that I just watched. (Another sidenote: if you are interested in this history, you can check out
After Ellen for a fairly good history of television's portrayal of GLBT topic matters).
This episode of Bones centered around half of a body that was found in the ocean. Bones initially identifies the body as female because of the breast implants and facial structure of the victim. Throughout the episode it becomes clear that the victim, Patricia, used to be Patrick.
This is important because the episode continues to portray Patricia with all the respect she was due. When Booth expresses confusion over what to call her, he eventually requests that everyone call her "she" because she was due that respect. When her family is questioned, Patricia's ex-wife is disgusted, but the staff at the Jeffersonian stand up for Patricia.
Her son is actually happy that it happened, that his father was given the opportunity to change and earn redemption.
Patricia was portrayed as a paster of a church called Inclusion Church, where everyone was welcome. I can't believe FOX allowed that to go on the air.
The episode ended with a) Patricia's death having NOTHING to do with her transition, but rather a jealous wife killing her because she though her husband was cheating on her with Patricia and b) with a sermon on how everybody is the same inside, no matter what they are like on the outside.
Okay, so the ending was a little cheesy. Still, this was by far one of the best displays of transgender issues on television that I've seen in a long time.
Next time? Hopefully the transgender character doesn't get killed off.
~~
in other news? Numb3rs this week had a female being kidnapped and the FBI questioned her partner, didn't get her name. Very small section of inclusion, but it wasn't sensationalized, it was treated as normal (which, btw, it IS). These two shows together made me happy.