tommckayisgay ([info]tommckayisgay) wrote in [info]1bruce1,
@ 2008-05-11 17:46:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Entry tags:bruce patman, miss lila fowler, racism, recapper: tommckayisgay, sweet valley high, trusty boyfriend todd

SVH #81 - Rosa's Lie


First off, the cover for this is just amazing.  Rosa’s left boob is at least three cups larger than her right.  Not to mention the high-waisted jeans the twins are wearing and the purple wannabe trenchcoat that Jessica is rocking.  And she DOES rock it!  At any rate, it’s the perfect way to show the difference between two American girls and one “chicana” (as Rosa continually calls herself).  And, as the book tells us, real chicana women have curves.  The book is not at all un-PC, as you can tell…..
 

The A plot featuring Rosa and her family (who are, oddly enough, never mentioned again that I’m aware of) is amazing – that is, amazingly lame.  The real genius is the B plot: Bruce vs. Todd is a battle of wills for their Phi Epsilon fraternity!!

 You can tell the book’s going to be fantastic when it opens with Liz feeding Todd orange slices and talking about the reason for lunch period.  Todd agrees with Liz that its purpose is to eat.  Or, at his so eloquently phrases it, “The need to refuel the body.”  Oh, Todd.  I’m swooning over here.


At this lunch hour, Jessica “pushed the straps of her orange tank top aside to bare her sun-bronzed shoulders” (actual quote).  Enter description of Liz and Jessica’s perfect features and differences.  It is decided at this lunch period that Phi Beta Alpha (henceforth referred to as PBA – SVH’s elite sorority!) and Phi Epsilon (henceforth referred to as PE – SVH’s elite fraternity of which Todd and Bruce are both members…. For the record, who the crap has heard of this fraternity in any other book?) are in need of new blood. 


New student Rose/Rosa is introduced walking by.  The girls admire her perfect pale skin (WTF? I thought everyone in Sweet Valley wanted to be sun-bronzed) and dark hair (WTF again?  I thought everyone is Sweet Valley was blonde or had red hair – the girls, anyway).  Then again, Rose /Rosa (Rosa is her Mexican name – and past! – she’s trying to shed) is an ethnic, much like Jade Wu or whatever other stock character a book introduces for the sole purpose to exploit their differences, and so of COURSE her ethnic features are to be admired!


Turns out, people like Rose, even though she’s new and they don’t know her well.  She seems nice and is asked out by at least ten guys (!!!  Seriously, this is mentioned in the book!!!) so Liz nominates her for PBA membership, along with some other random people we’ll never hear about again.  When she’s mentioned for membership, Amy decides a good thing about Rose/Rosa is “She’s never dated Bruce Patman!” 


I would date Bruce Patman.  Just to cruise around in 1Bruce1.


Incidentally, when the guys (meaning Winston and Todd) talk about why they lost interest in PE, we get this gem: ““I still can’t help seeing one big obnoxious obstacle to progress: good ol’ ‘One Bruce One,’” said Winston, referring to the license plate on Bruce’s black Porsche.”


It is so awesome how he refers to Bruce by his license plate!


Moving on.  We get backstory about Rose/Rosa.  She complains that she wants to be American and not Mexican.  Because obviously, in Southern California, it is so hard to be both.  I thought we were having a problem with illegal immigrants?


 But I digress. 


Rose/Rosa thinks all Mexicans must hang out with each other and that if it’s revealed that she’s a “chicana” (and yes, she calls herself a chicana multiple times), she’ll be shunned.  And who would want to miss out on PBA?  So when they ask her about her background, she makes up a TOTALLY realistic sounding story about how she moved here from Boston, her ancestors came over on the Mayflower, she and her family went to England the previous summer, where she met Princess Di and Fergie and found out she is distantly related to Queen Elizabeth and about five hundredth in line for the throne!!  All the PBAs are impressed.  In reality, Rose/Rosa lived in Texas before this.  How cliché, no? 


When the PBA meeting disbands, Sandy’s boyfriend Manuel Lopez (what a clever name!) comes to pick Sandy up, and Lila wrinkles her nose and says, “I don’t know how she can date him.  He’s so ethnic and working-class.”  Oh, Lila!  Rose/Rosa internalizes this and thinks, “The Pi Betas must never find out the truth about her.”  Dum dum DUMMMMMMMMMMM.


PBA comes up with lame rush dares, like breaking into the boy’s locker room, giving Chrome Dome Cooper a toupee, and writing a love letter to a nerd.  They give the easiest tasks to Rose/Rosa because, you know, she’s related to royalty, after all.


More exciting are the tasks that PE comes up with!  They have 4 pledges – 2 nominated by Bruce and 2 nominated by Todd.  It is decided that Todd and Bruce should come up with tasks for each other’s pledges.  And this is where the true awesomeness begins. 


Bruce ingeniously tasks Todd’s pledges with climbing the front wall of school and move the clock’s hands ahead one hour – WITHOUT using a ladder!  Todd responds by challenging Bruce’s pledges to borrow a bus and return to school with a dozen pizzas in half an hour.  He’ll be timing them.  Todd is, after all, the type to wear a watch. 


Enter ever-concerned, ever-meddling Liz Wakefield, who involves herself in fraternity affairs and declares both Todd and Bruce “elitists.”  They blow her off.  As they should.  Both sets of pledges successfully complete their tasks.  Here’s hoping they’ll come up with better dares for the second tasks.


We go to PBA’s pledges, who have been tasked with starting a food fight in the cafeteria.  BADASS.


Thankfully, no time is wasted going back to PE’s pledges.  For the second set, uber-nerd Todd Wilkins decides that Bruce’s pledges have until the end of the school day (without cutting class!) to check out 100 books from the SVH library that contain the word “challenge” or “pressure” in the title.  Wow.  If that was my task, I would not want to join this fraternity.


Bruce, in only slightly better pledgemaster form, instructs Todd’s pledges to take the office furniture out of the guidance counselor’s office and put it on the grass (again, without cutting class and before the end of the school day!). 


Some PBAs come over to Rose/Rosa’s house, where she lies and says she hasn’t unpacked photos of her and Princess Di yet.  Things are okay over there, and she starts to feel like she could actually pass as an American girl, since apparently living in America does not automatically make her feel this way.  She NEEDS to be in PBA.  Nothing else will do.  But oh no!  Just as she feels like she can actually have friends over and it’ll be okay, her parents drop a horrible bombshell on her: Nana’s coming to visit from rural Mexico!  CRAP!  Rose/Rosa hasn’t seen her in three years!  And she doesn’t speak English! 


Nana arrives.  She’s described as “a tiny, plump, white-haired woman in a shapeless flowered dress.”  Because, as we all know, that’s what every Nana in Mexico wears.  Nana disapproves of Rose/Rosa’s short skirt (I wonder what she’d think of Jessica pushing her straps down…?) but is thrilled to see her granddaughter.  Rose/Rosa is only kind of happy to see her and is counting down the days till she leaves, since until then, she’s stuck “babysitting” Nana and avoiding her new PBA friends so they won’t find out the truth.


Back to the awesomeness that is Todd vs. Bruce. 


Meddling Liz shows up at Todd’s house and sits by while a PE meeting goes on.  Todd and Bruce complain about the way the other’s pledges completed the last dare.  The other PE members start leaving because of the increasing tension between the two!  Just when it seems like things have heated up enough for a Todd punch to be thrown – Winston “literally thrust himself between them.”  Damn you, Winston.


Nana and Rose/Rosa continue to spend time together, with Nana teaching Rose/Rosa about her Mexican heritage and taking her shopping.  Nana also gives her a cooking lesson and Rose/Rosa has this realization: “She was a chicana and if someone looked down on her because of that, it was their prejudice, their problem, not hers.”  Whoa.  Deep. 


The PBA girls realize Rose/Rosa’s avoiding them and make her, as her last dare, throw a party for them at her house.  Rose/Rosa gets her parents and Nana out of the house.  The PBAs catch sight of Nana leaving and Rose/Rosa lies and says it’s just “the cleaning lady.”  Lila commiserates when Rose/Rosa says she “just babbles away in Spanish.  I never have the vaguest idea what she’s talking about!”  Because again, as we all know, every cleaning lady is Mexican and does not speak English?  Rose/Rosa also decides to dump out a perfectly good cake that Nana made with love for her and her friends to enjoy because it had a Mexican design and scripted Spanish words. Rose/Rosa is clearly part of the problem, not the solution, when it comes to prejudice…


The last Todd vs. Bruce challenge!  Both sets of pledges have received warnings from their respective sports teams about not getting involved in any more shenanigans.  However, Bruce decides Todd’s pledges have to take the pompoms of the opposite team’s cheerleaders at the next basketball game.  Todd retaliates by saying Bruce’s pledges need to take the opposing team’s tennis racket’s covers at the next match. Oooohh.  This is way harsh. 


Jess and Liz don’t see either set of PE pledges accomplishing this task.  But!  As it is later shown, the two sets of pledges helped each other out in the spirit of brotherhood.  Take a lesson, Todd and Bruce.  This is what a fraternity should be. 


Back to Rose/Rosa’s identity crisis.  At a picnic where the pledges wait on the PBAs hand and foot and wave palm fans for them, a little girl falls into a well.  And, oh no, she only speaks Spanish!  Only Rose/Rosa can talk to her and save her!  But does she have the courage to embrace her heritage?!?


Yes!!!  She talks to this little girl, which apparently saves her life.  The PBAs are SHOCKED to find out the truth about Rosa. (You mean her ancestors didn’t arrive on the Mayflower?)  Rose/Rosa’s confession:  “I’m not that girl.  I’m… Mexican.”


The PBAs are silent.  She leaves.


The PBAs follow Rose/Rosa home and all except for Lila appear to be accepting of her heritage.  (“Don’t worry, Rose,” Lila assured her.  “We understand why you did what you id.  And you can bet your secret is safe with us.  No one else has to know you’re Mexican!”)


So Rose/Rosa and all the other pledges are inducted into PBA.  But wait!  When it’s Rose/Rosa’s turn, she declines!  She gives this gem of a speech: “I can’t join Pi Beta Alpha because I’m ROSA Jameson, not Rose Jameson.”  (Identity crisis over!)   Rosa tries to leave, but the other girls clustered around her and want to hug her and “make her swear she would still socialize with them even though she had decided not to join the sorority.”  Rosa invites them over and says she’ll make them Mexican food.


And that’s the end of Rose/Rosa Jameson in Sweet Valley High. 


Oh, there’s also some lame C plot about Jessica feeling ignored by Sam and her family and doing poorly in math.  All leading up to #82 – Kidnapped by the Cult!  (“How far will Jessica go to get the attention she needs?”)


 


(Post a new comment)


[info]fancynewbrookly
2008-05-12 01:02 am UTC (link)
NOOOOOOOOOOO! I've been working on a recap for this since January, i was just so busy, i didn't get a chance to finish it! Darn it!!!!!

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]tommckayisgay
2008-05-12 01:45 am UTC (link)
This book is such a gem, it's worth at LEAST two recaps. I say, bring it on!

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]fancynewbrookly
2008-05-12 01:55 am UTC (link)
Thanks, but mine won't live up to yours. And oh my god, i just saw your username!!! That is MADE of win.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]thedilettante
2008-05-12 09:22 am UTC (link)
three recaps! I hope?I have half of one written too!

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]kakeochi_umai
2008-05-12 11:51 am UTC (link)
+1 for best username EVAH. And the icon just completes it. XD

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]lemonsherry
2008-05-12 01:18 am UTC (link)
At a picnic where the pledges wait on the PBAs hand and foot and wave palm fans for them, a little girl falls into a well. And, oh no, she only speaks Spanish! Only Rose/Rosa can talk to her and save her! But does she have the courage to embrace her heritage?!?

I lol'd.

(Reply to this)


[info]dustkitten
2008-05-12 01:35 am UTC (link)
Great recap.

I'm not sure what you're trying to say about them using the word "chicana" though??

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]tommckayisgay
2008-05-12 01:44 am UTC (link)
Thanks! I didn't mean to offend with the chicana bit. I live in Southern California and I've met people who call themselves Mexican or Mexican-American but no one who's called themselves chicana even once, though I know it's a valid term. The ghostwriter used this word (and a few other stock Mexican words) repeatedly, like they found these words in the dictionary and did not bother to learn any others (and honestly, did they need to? The first time I read this book over a decade ago, I probably thought they had a firm grasp on the Spanish language and on the cultural divide... ;-) ).

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]dustkitten
2008-05-12 01:54 am UTC (link)
I think "chicano/chicana" was the self-applied way to refer to Mexicans and Mexican-Americans in the '70s and maybe the '80s, so it probably has a lot to do with when the book was written. We never heard chicano/chicana here in Jersey growing up, but then again, we lived in a half-white, half-black town until right after we started school, then we moved to a town that was almost completely white. I always thought that it was like the "Afro-American" of the Latino community--a short-lived term that gave way to "Latino/Latina" later, but someone else would have to answer that one. I have no clue, and Wikipedia is making me even more tired. :/

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]fauxkaren
2008-05-12 02:12 am UTC (link)
Chicano/a generally is something that refers to native born Mexican Americans. It was something that people who identified as such fought to have seen as a separate classification from Mexican or Mexican-American. It was a big deal in the 70s/80s, but now I think the preferred term is "latino/a" at least here in SoCal.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]strangerface
2008-05-12 01:25 pm UTC (link)
I think it's the ghostwriter trying to say, "Hey! Look, I did some half-assed research on Mexican-Americas! Let me use this word over and over and the reader will think I am s-m-r-t."

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]washie
2008-05-12 02:26 am UTC (link)
“Don’t worry, Rose,” Lila assured her. “We understand why you did what you did. And you can bet your secret is safe with us. No one else has to know you’re Mexican!”


Is this an actual quote?!??

My God.

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]tommckayisgay
2008-05-12 04:00 am UTC (link)
Of course it's an exact quote (page 140)! Would you expect anything less from Sweet Valley, which always handles sensitive issues in the most tactful and unoffensive way? ;-)

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]washie
2008-05-12 04:03 am UTC (link)
If Sweet Valley were a person, I bet she'd be the type who'd say, "I'm not racist! I have a black friend!"

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]suzloua
2008-05-13 04:17 pm UTC (link)
hee - I can't remember what it was, but I was watching something the other day and a character said "I'm not racist! Some of my best friends live next door to black people!" V funny.

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]washie
2008-05-13 05:08 pm UTC (link)
It's the classic crappy defense, akin to: "I'm not homophobic! This guy I work with is gay and I don't hate him! I just think it's weird and gross, but I don't HATE gays!"

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]enogitna
2008-05-12 02:55 am UTC (link)
I remember this book! I read it when I was young and impressionable! >.<;; Now I realize it's true lame-ness.

(Reply to this)


[info]ifandonlyif
2008-05-12 02:59 am UTC (link)
i HATED when rosa threw out the cake. i wanted to cry, first of all because it was so sweet of nana and second of all because i love cake. why couldn't she just have saved it for later?

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]appleredhair
2008-05-12 03:53 am UTC (link)
Me TOO. Jeez, that was horrid.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]enogitna
2008-05-12 04:09 am UTC (link)
That part really stuck out to me. That and the part where Jessica said she thought Rosa's house would be "Paul Revere" style. Because Paul Revere was an interior designer.

(okay I had 1 glass of wine with dinner and it must have been "magic" wine from the same place that made the vodka in Night to Remember because I am barely type... )

Edited at 2008-05-12 04:10 am UTC

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]atdelphi
2008-05-13 04:51 am UTC (link)
Not an interior designer, but he was a silversmith and later a manufacturer of metal goods - there's a style of pottery and other housewares known as "Paul Revere Style."

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]lefaym
2008-05-12 04:50 am UTC (link)
Yep, count me in as another one who remembers this-- I didn't remember much else about this book, but I did remember the cake.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]svhhorseluvr
2008-05-12 04:59 am UTC (link)
I wants cake.

Me granddad's from Ireland. He drinks at the pub every night, says "Begorrah" before he speaks, grows potatoes he started in Ireland, and has red hair, yeh know?

Not really. Actually he's dead, bless'm. But that's how he'd be in Sweet Valley because EVERYONE FROM A DIFFERENT COUNTRY ACTS THE SAME ALL THE WAY.

I want cake!

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]loubeelou
2008-05-12 08:27 am UTC (link)
i wanted to cry, first of all because it was so sweet of nana and second of all because i love cake.

Me too! Who the hell throws out a quality cake? Especially made by a nana? Nanas make gooooood cakes. Or at least, mine do. Maybe Nana Chicana (haha rhymes) makes crap cake?

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]seaborne
2008-05-12 02:35 pm UTC (link)
yes! i hated that part oh so much. her poor nana :(

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]melody_powers
2008-05-12 08:07 pm UTC (link)
Absolutely agree. Please, at least tell me the cake wasn't chocolate... (sob)

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]asouthernthing
2008-05-12 05:51 am UTC (link)
I still can’t help seeing one big obnoxious obstacle to progress: good ol’ ‘One Bruce One'

This should be our official slogan.

(Reply to this)


[info]veracity
2008-05-12 07:40 am UTC (link)
You know, for a first book to read in the series, this was a lame one. Darn it being 25 cents back when it first came out. Darrrn it. I think I had it confused with a cooler book. Oops.

But I love how she doesn't accept it because it wasn't her name, and she totally blended in to the Sweet Valley scene instantaneously. Did she have a twang at all? No, wait. Of course not. Texas = Boston. How could I forget.

At least Todd and Bruce saved the book (and recap!).

(Reply to this)(Thread)


(Anonymous)
2008-05-12 08:32 am UTC (link)
Although, Sweet Valley residents have never left Cali, and have probably never heard a Boston OR Texas accent. So their ignorance totally makes it plausible!

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]veracity
2008-05-12 04:27 pm UTC (link)
Oh, so true. But people keep arriving from The Outside. It must mess with their center of the universe complex. How rude of them.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]strangerface
2008-05-12 01:27 pm UTC (link)
Do the frat pledges get in any trouble for all this tomfoolery or have the teachers given up caring by this point?

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]tommckayisgay
2008-05-12 07:48 pm UTC (link)
The only teacher who ever cares about anything is Mr. Collins, who goes above and BEYOND the call of duty. When are he and Liz going to get together anyways?

Ahem.

As for the pledges, nothing goes futher than a warning from their sports teams.

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]strangerface
2008-05-12 07:57 pm UTC (link)
They started food fights and stole buses and no one cared. That's kind awesome?

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]schmandalous
2008-05-12 02:21 pm UTC (link)
The cake thing makes me sad, too.

I totally remember not thinking about the implications of this one at all when I was younger, which is sort of awkward because holy damn, it's racist.

Also, how are they in Southern California and there aren't any Mexicans/Latinos/Hispanics, etc??? I don't mean that in any kind of a bad way, but the culture is pretty prevalent there, or so I thought. Why would anyone in SV be shocked about someone who's Mexican?

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]ahwannabe
2008-05-12 04:36 pm UTC (link)
Sweet Valley is full of Invisible Mexicans.

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]mochaloca85
2008-05-13 11:33 am UTC (link)
And on the day of the twins' 17th birthday, they just randomly appear to make SVSY totally boring.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]versipellis
2008-05-12 07:48 pm UTC (link)
It surprises me that Lila is so... overtly racist in this. I mean, she's always trotted out to snark on whoever is the current book's undesirable, but... are there any other examples of her being racist? Or, conversely, NOT being racist? I can't think of any myself.

(I suppose the 'ethnic and working class' comment is also classist, which is more canon for Lila...)

(Reply to this)(Thread)


(Anonymous)
2008-05-12 08:44 pm UTC (link)
I agree, I don't like how whoever wrote this one juse used Lila as the mouthpiece of racism or whatever, when it seems out of character. I can't think of any previous examples either, I don't think she's any more racist than anyone else in WASPy Sweet Valley, who mostly seem pretty ignorant. Meh.

Also, the twins on the cover of this one look much more like the 12-year old Twins, especially Jess, if slightly bigger.

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


(Anonymous)
2008-05-12 09:07 pm UTC (link)
*just. D'oh. And on the subject of the cover again, Liz in the background totally looks like she's studiously copying Jess' stance so one day she, too, might look cool - hair dangling over right shoulder, left hand slung casually into jeans pocket... but looking pretty miffed that Jess is leaning on Rosa and smiling rather than merely laying a hand on that shoulder and shaking her head condescendingly. She just doesn't get it, Liz! *sigh*

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]versipellis
2008-05-13 12:02 pm UTC (link)
Liz looks really marginalised. Why does she not get to lay a caring hand on Rosa's shoulder? Horrors!

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]versipellis
2008-05-13 12:01 pm UTC (link)
Yeah, they do, don't they? Similar art style. (Although I now can't stop staring at Rosa's breasts after the OP's comment...)

(Reply to this)(Parent)

Are you sure she wasn't goth...
(Anonymous)
2008-05-15 10:16 pm UTC (link)
"The girls admire her perfect pale skin (WTF? I thought everyone in Sweet Valley wanted to be sun-bronzed)"

Not to mention that Rose/Rosa, would be NATURALLY "sun-bronzed" in real life, since she IS hispanic... skin bleaching cream for the new school year, perhaps? Confused! I never read this one when I was younger so... ew! As a woman of color, I'm pretty sure I would have been thrown off the series after reading it. I know it's SV and everything, but come on! I dwell on this because everything else that's wrong with this book has been pretty well covered, but BOOOOOOOOOOOOO! :-P

(Reply to this)(Thread)

Bianca Reagan says
(Anonymous)
2008-05-15 11:37 pm UTC (link)
Hispanic people come in all shades, from powder white to midnight black. There are white Mexicans and black Mexicans and Asian Mexicans and Indian Mexicans (both Native American and East Indian). So Rosa could have had pale skin. I've known multiple Mexican people who do.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]sour_hill
2008-05-30 04:44 am UTC (link)
(“Don’t worry, Rose,” Lila assured her. “We understand why you did what you id. And you can bet your secret is safe with us. No one else has to know you’re Mexican!”)


Odd that the gostwriter had Lila say that as it is something I could totally see Sutton saying.

(Reply to this)


Create an Account
Forgot your login?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…